Skip to main content

Home/ Diigo Community/ Better tagging suggestions suggestion
Soul Book

Better tagging suggestions suggestion - 85 views

tagging suggestion toolbar idea

started by Soul Book on 03 Feb 09
  • Soul Book
    #1 Soul Book on 03 Feb 09
     
    I was thinking about how to make it easier to quickly tag bookmarks, and this is what i came up with:

    http://i121.photobucket.com/albums/o208/soulgrind_bucket/random/diigoadd.jpg

    First of all it'd be useful to have a "as last bookmark" button for when you are tagging a load of pages one after the other that are all similar.

    Next it'd be good to get recommendations not just based on the page, but based on your search queries* (if they are in the page) and the tags you use most often.

    *if i've searched for "free activities tokyo" then its probably a good way to tag it, as i'll probably search for it that way again. But we need to check if those words are in the page, as tabbed browsing might mean the search is for another tab.

    Also, if i'm adding it to a list (or group) then suggesting tags from that list/group would make sense. There should be a checkbox to automatically add all the tags for the list/group. This checkbox should remember it's setting.

    Finally, move the "private" checkbox down by the "save" button, and then there's a small chance i might actually remember to use it correctly from time to time.
  • Soul Book
    #2 Soul Book on 03 Feb 09
     
    Additionally, have the following settings:

    Defaults:

    Bookmarks: (_)private
    Quick Bookmarks: (_)private (_)add search keywords as tags*
    Unread: (_)private (_) add search keywords as tags

    to allow different settings for privacy, etc.. for different kinds of bookmarks.

    *but only if in the page
  • Graham Perrin
    #3 Graham Perrin on 03 Feb 09
     
    Nice mock up :)

    Four or more additional considerations:

    1. share to a group should present suggestions based on the group tag dictionary

    2. share to a group might present yet more suggestions based on the tags of group members that are not included within the dictionary

    3. dialogue might invite user to add to multiple lists

    4. dialogue might invite user to add to multiple groups

    - all of which in combination could mean, a whole lotta stuff in a single dialogue ;)

    AFAIR Natetronn (Nate) Jackson offered a mock up that demonstrated options 3 and 4.

    Need to think ahead about how much can/should be squeezed into the bookmark dialogue.

    Risk of the mass not fitting within the display of, say, an Eee PC.

    I'm still tending towards keeping it simple/essential at time of bookmarking, refining after the event.

    Best,
    Graham

    Postscripts: tidying, completion of unfinished sentences, words were missing etc.
  • Graham Perrin
    #6 Graham Perrin on 07 Feb 09
     
    > one button … Click once … double click … right click

    I wonder about accessibility.

    Not knocking the ideas :)

    Just kicking the ball around.

    -
    Postscript: sorry! I strayed way beyond your subject line

    > Better tagging suggestions suggestion

    My thoughts (completely different) are now in a separate topic,
    http://groups.diigo.com/Diigo_HQ/forum/topic/a-faster-more-compact-dialogue-41261
  • anonymous
    #12 anonymous on 19 Feb 09
     
    Really Great Idea. im quite Impressed :) . Diigo plz consider this very useful idea .
  • Graham Perrin
    #13 Graham Perrin on 28 Mar 09
     
    Both http://groups.diigo.com/Diigo_HQ/bookmark/tag/tag and http://groups.diigo.com/Diigo_HQ/bookmark/tag/tagging are relatively sparse at the moment, those of you with an interest in tagging might like to tag relevant bookmarks with one or both of tag and tagging:)

To Top

Start a New Topic » « Back to the Diigo Community group