Opinion | The Future of Nonconformity - The New York Times - 0 views
www.nytimes.com/...stack-newsletters-writers.html
history culture intellectual conformity openness diversity exclusion anti-intellectualism
![](/images/link.gif)
-
Like other realms, American intellectual life has been marked by a series of exclusions
-
The oldest and vastest was the exclusion of people of color from the commanding institutions of our culture.
-
Today, there’s the exclusion of conservatives from academic life. Then there’s the exclusion of working-class voices from mainstream media.
- ...20 more annotations...
-
Then there’s the marginalization of those with radical critiques — from say, the Marxist left and the theological right.
-
Intellectual exclusion and segregation have been terrible for America, poisoning both the right and the left.
-
For many on the right the purpose of thinking changed. Thinking was no longer for understanding. Thinking was for belonging.
-
Thinking itself became suspect. Sarah Palin and Donald Trump reintroduced anti-intellectualism into the American right: a distrust of the media, expertise and facts
-
Conservatives were told their voices didn’t matter, and many reacted in a childish way that seemed to justify that exclusion. A corrosive spirit of resentment and victimhood spread across the American right — an intellectual inferiority complex combined with a moral superiority complex.
-
fragility. When you make politics the core of your religious identity, and you shield yourself from heresy, then any glimpse of that heresy is going to provoke an extreme emotional reaction.
-
conformity. Writers are now expected to write as a representative of a group, in order to affirm the self-esteem of the group. Predictability is the point.
-
Now the boundaries of exclusion are shifting again. What we erroneously call “cancel culture” is an attempt to shift the boundaries of the sayable so it excludes not only conservatives but liberals and the heterodox as well
-
Sixty-two percent of Americans say they are afraid to share things they believe, according to a poll
-
A majority of staunch progressives say they feel free to share their political views, but majorities of liberals, moderates and conservatives are afraid to.
-
49 percent of Americans say the cancel culture has a negative impact on society and only 27 say it has a positive impact
-
The next good thing is there are no ads, just subscription revenue. Online writers don’t have to chase clicks by writing about whatever Trump tweeted 15 seconds ago.
-
It’s possible that the debate now going on stupidly on Twitter can migrate to newsletters. It’s possible that writers will bundle, with established writers promoting promising ones. It’s possible that those of us at the great remaining mainstream outlets will be enmeshed in conversations that are more freewheeling and thoughtful.
-
I’m hoping the definition of a pundit changes — not a foot soldier out for power, but a person who argues in order to come closer to understanding.