Less than a week after the attacks in Paris — while the public and policymakers were still reeling, and the investigation had barely gotten off the ground — Cy Vance, Manhattan’s District Attorney, released a policy paper calling for legislation requiring companies to provide the government with backdoor access to their smartphones and other mobile devices. This is the first concrete proposal of this type since September 2014, when FBI Director James Comey reignited the “Crypto Wars” in response to Apple’s and Google’s decisions to use default encryption on their smartphones. Though Comey seized on Apple’s and Google’s decisions to encrypt their devices by default, his concerns are primarily related to end-to-end encryption, which protects communications that are in transit. Vance’s proposal, on the other hand, is only concerned with device encryption, which protects data stored on phones.
It is still unclear whether encryption played any role in the Paris attacks, though we do know that the attackers were using unencrypted SMS text messages on the night of the attack, and that some of them were even known to intelligence agencies and had previously been under surveillance. But regardless of whether encryption was used at some point during the planning of the attacks, as I lay out below, prohibiting companies from selling encrypted devices would not prevent criminals or terrorists from being able to access unbreakable encryption.
Vance’s primary complaint is that Apple’s and Google’s decisions to provide their customers with more secure devices through encryption interferes with criminal investigations. He claims encryption prevents law enforcement from accessing stored data like iMessages, photos and videos, Internet search histories, and third party app data. He makes several arguments to justify his proposal to build backdoors into encrypted smartphones, but none of them hold water.
Group items matching
in title, tags, annotations or url
2More
2More
Crypto wars redux: why the FBI's desire to unlock your private life must be resisted | ... - 1 views
2More
U.S. 'Strikes' Scheme Fails to Impact Piracy Landscape | TorrentFreak - 0 views
3More
Pirate Bay Founder Peter Sunde Shouldn't Be in Jail, MEP Says | TorrentFreak - 0 views
1More
Court: Cox Willingly Failed to Disconnect Pirating Subscribers - TorrentFreak - 1 views
11More
Cy Vance's Proposal to Backdoor Encrypted Devices Is Riddled With Vulnerabilities | Jus... - 0 views
3More
Sony Sued For Not Protecting Leaked Movie From Pirates - TorrentFreak [# ! Note] - 0 views
2More
'Failed' Piracy Letters Should Escalate to Fines & Jail, MP Says | TorrentFreak - 0 views
1More
Putin: Pirate Site Blocking Has Failed to End Piracy | TorrentFreak - 0 views
2More
The six tech policy problems Congress failed to fix this year | Ars Technica - 1 views
2More
Spain's Ill-Conceived 'Google Tax' Law Likely To Cause Immense Damage To Digital Common... - 1 views
2More
Internet Pirates Always a Step Ahead , Aussies Say | TorrentFreak - 0 views
1More
Unprecedented Music Piracy Collapse Fails to Boost Revenues | TorrentFreak - 0 views
2More
MPAA to Undergo Major Changes Following Studio Disquiet | TorrentFreak - 0 views
2More
ISP's "Three Strikes" Scheme is Weird and Broken | TorrentFreak - 0 views
3More
Editorial: Wikipedia fails as an encyclopedia, to science's detriment | Ars Technica UK... - 0 views
1More