Created a group (gpwebsite). Full details (copy/pasted)...
Group Name: GPwebsite
Description: no description
Interests: no_tag
Category: Not Categorized
Who can view? Private - only members can view
Searchable? Do not list this group
How to join? Apply to join -- moderator approval required
Who can invite new members? All group members
Originally I had "How to join?" set to "invitation only". Then I change it to "Apply to join".
However, if I try to open the group URL (http://groups.diigo.com/groups/gpwebsite) in another browser, it says, "the group you requested was not found or you are not allow to access".
Also, if I go to http://groups.diigo.com/group_mana/group_manage?group_name=gpwebsite and click "Edit" next to "Group Details", it is set to "By invitation only". I've changed to "apply to join" and clicked "save" several times. Now it shows as above on the group management page, but still shows "by invitation only" marked when I click edit.
So, how can people join the group if I don't invite them. (Would be super cool if there was a secret URL or something.)
Any help or suggestions appriciated. I tried searching help and the forum, but no luck. I have a large (hundreds) number of people who potentially could end up joining the group. I don't want to have to invite them all.
Maybe worth saying a bit more about what I'm trying to do with this group. It's probably not relevant to the bug report, but maybe someone has helpful suggestions.
Goal: A distributed website design brainstorm with people from all over the world.
I work for a large non-profit organization, and am leading the project to redesign their websites. I want to give people a chance to input by suggesting sites the design team should look at, and saying what they love/hate about those sites ("oh, the menu is done really well here" or "I think we might want to use the same sort of layout", that kind of thing).
I want anyone in the organization (1,000+ staff) to be able to participate, plus a limited number of supporters/members. (It's not a secret process, but I don't want to open it up too widely because we'd be overwhelmed with input.) I'm guessing a couple dozen people will take part, but you never know with these things. It might grab people's interest.
At the end, the design team will take all of this input, and use it as the raw fodder for their look/feel development.
Can I send that URL to anyone? (They then sign up to Diigo and I approve them as members?) Is there a way to do it without me having to approve anyone? Since it's a short term project (and not really secret), I am not worried about the URL getting out to more people.
(Andrew: I'm constructing those URLs. Please be reassured that I don't actually see your group management interface.)
> I've changed to "apply to join" and clicked "save" several times. > Now it shows as above on the group management page, but still > shows "by invitation only" marked when I click edit.
Maybe bug, maybe user error.
Problem description:
Created a group (gpwebsite). Full details (copy/pasted)...
Group Name: GPwebsite
Description: no description
Interests: no_tag
Category: Not Categorized
Who can view? Private - only members can view
Searchable? Do not list this group
How to join? Apply to join -- moderator approval required
Who can invite
new members? All group members
Originally I had "How to join?" set to "invitation only". Then I change it to "Apply to join".
However, if I try to open the group URL (http://groups.diigo.com/groups/gpwebsite) in another browser, it says, "the group you requested was not found or you are not allow to access".
Also, if I go to http://groups.diigo.com/group_mana/group_manage?group_name=gpwebsite
and click "Edit" next to "Group Details", it is set to "By invitation only". I've changed to "apply to join" and clicked "save" several times. Now it shows as above on the group management page, but still shows "by invitation only" marked when I click edit.
So, how can people join the group if I don't invite them. (Would be super cool if there was a secret URL or something.)
Any help or suggestions appriciated. I tried searching help and the forum, but no luck. I have a large (hundreds) number of people who potentially could end up joining the group. I don't want to have to invite them all.
Maybe worth saying a bit more about what I'm trying to do with this group. It's probably not relevant to the bug report, but maybe someone has helpful suggestions.
Goal: A distributed website design brainstorm with people from all over the world.
I work for a large non-profit organization, and am leading the project to redesign their websites. I want to give people a chance to input by suggesting sites the design team should look at, and saying what they love/hate about those sites ("oh, the menu is done really well here" or "I think we might want to use the same sort of layout", that kind of thing).
I want anyone in the organization (1,000+ staff) to be able to participate, plus a limited number of supporters/members. (It's not a secret process, but I don't want to open it up too widely because we'd be overwhelmed with input.) I'm guessing a couple dozen people will take part, but you never know with these things. It might grab people's interest.
At the end, the design team will take all of this input, and use it as the raw fodder for their look/feel development.
Any ideas or suggestions are welcome. Thanks!
I invited myself to join and got an email with a URL like this...
http://groups.diigo.com/talk/after_sign_and_join_group/gpwebsite/[BIG LONG STRING]
Can I send that URL to anyone? (They then sign up to Diigo and I approve them as members?) Is there a way to do it without me having to approve anyone? Since it's a short term project (and not really secret), I am not worried about the URL getting out to more people.
> Who can view? Private - only members can view
> if I try to open the group URL … in another browser, it says, "…
> you are not allow to access".
That denial of access (denial of viewing) is harmonious with your setting visibility to members only.
> I invited myself to join
For as long as you have one or more *open* invitations at your
http://groups.diigo.com/group_mana/member_manage?group_name=gpwebsite then in the Open invitations tab, you will find the 'Invite URL' alongside the name every invitation that is open.
I suspect that if two or more invitations are open, then
in each row the Invite URL is the same.
@ Diigo
To me it does seem a bug in Diigo Groups workflow that:
when you have no open invitations, neither
http://groups.diigo.com/group_mana/invite_others?group_name=gpwebsite nor
http://groups.diigo.com/group_mana/member_manage?group_name=gpwebsite will express the URL (the ticket) through which non-members may be invited.
(Andrew: I'm constructing those URLs. Please be reassured that I don't actually see your group management interface.)
> I've changed to "apply to join" and clicked "save" several times.
> Now it shows as above on the group management page, but still
> shows "by invitation only" marked when I click edit.
That behaviour sounds possibly buggy.
Regards
Graham
You're right, I can share that link around, and any Diigo user that clicks on it joins the group.
Perfect!
Cheers,
Andrew
To Top