Journal #1:Guided Reading in inclusive Middle Years Classrooms - 3 views
-
Gina Dettloff on 28 Jan 12Lyons, W. & Thompson, S.A. (2011, October). Guided Reading in inclusive Middle Years Classrooms. intervention in School and Clinic, 47: 158. Retrieved January 27, 2012, from http://isc.sagepub.com.huaryu.kl.oakland.edu/content/47/3/158.full.pdf This study was interesting, because it focuses on something that I am sure so many teachers struggle with - how to teach students who demonstrate a wide variety/range of ability and needs. This study took a really "rough" socioeconomic level of 4th -8th graders and their teachers, and using guided reading as their main method of instruction DID see an 80% of students advance at least one, if not more levels. This was attributed to the fact that in small guided reading groups teachers could spend more time with small groups of students, targeting individual needs. That was the warm fuzzy. Of course, the part that this article mentions in the end, and would stop most teachers in their tracks before attempting to duplicate this, is that each classroom was equipped with several teachers and teacher assistants to make this work. Additionally, there were many times where the rest of the class NOT consisting of the 3 to 5 students in the guided reading group were supposed to work independently. All in all, every study has its flaws - the interesting thing here is that despite them, students still improved overall.
- ...1 more comment...
-
Linda Clinton on 28 Jan 12Gina, nice job on the critique. Because this article was retrieved through OU, please provide the complete citation with author(s), date, journal title, volume & number. Also bring a printout of the article to class or (preferably) email it to me if possible. :)
-
Gina Dettloff on 28 Jan 12oops...ok I edited my post and stuck the citation in it...thanks!
-
Linda Clinton on 28 Jan 12InterestIng to note some of the different terms used In the Canadian Schools, such as "families livIng In vulnerable circumstances" and "enhanced fundIng." Probably akIn to our use of "at-risk" and "Title I." You are right, most teachers would "stop In their tracks" with regard to the two teachers. This article refers to an Inclusion settIng, In which the special ed teacher "pushes In" with the special ed students and co-teaches with the gen ed teacher. I did a NCA QAR visit last sprIng In a school with 4 or 5 teachers In a grade, and 4 paras In the school. It was either 2nd or 3rd grade. Every day at the designated time, all the paras would go Into that pod of the school, and the students would move around to different teachers or paras and everyone got guided readIng every day. It requires a shift In thInkIng and lots of collaboration and cooperation, but it can be done.