T531 Summer 2012

This article makes a great point about an achievement gap statistic. A black or Hispanic 12th grader has reading and math skills comparable to a white 8th grader. I appreciate this article because there are no excuses, just a desire to fix what is broken.

I appreciate the reality of this article. Normally, I get upset when I read about educational reform; however, this article laid out a truth to reform. I agree that the decisions of our government went "the wrong way on education." But, I appreciate Booker's message: "I am no longer concerned with right and left. I just want to go forward!" This is what we all need to focus on. Our students. They need to be what we fight for.

Yet another article about school reform that completely leaves the role of parents out. Until parents have the ability to support their children at home and set high, achievable expectations, true reform will never be possible. Unfortunately, this is one aspect of that administrators cannot control, no matter how many reform plans they invent or enact.

This article discusses how teachers who work to improve students test scores are leaving a lasting impression on their students. The more education they are getting by "good teachers" increases the students chances of succeeding. Teachers are working to improve these students test scores and while they are doing this the students are learning more than just what is needed to pass the tests. Schools need better teachers to help students in the long run.

"Mr. Jones might regularly help raise test scores more than Ms. Smith, but maybe that is because his students are from wealthier families, or because he has a harder-working class - factors that can be difficult for researchers to discern. " This quote stood out to me because it is similar to the argument against merit based pay for teachers in Indiana. We all know that students come to us with an array of prior knowledge, much of which is based on previous experiences and their environment. However, all students are capable of academic growth. What's the harm in evaluating teachers based on the growth their students made during the school year?

I knew I want to be a teacher since fourth and fifth grade when I had Mr. Cearfoss. He was one of those effective teachers who changed my life by making me feel successful on a daily basis and believe that I could be successful on a daily basis if I saw value in everything I did. Kind of deep for a fourth and fifth grade teacher, but I remember him attending my baseball games late in the evenings and calling home when he thought I was slacking. He made it clear to me, and the rest of the students, that while he cared about our education in his classroom, he cared even more that we used our education to make the right decisions in our lives after we left his classroom. The average effect of one teacher on a single student is modest. I did not find it surprising that, according to the article, "All else equal, a student with one excellent teacher for one year between fourth and eighth grade would gain $4,600 in lifetime income, compared to a student of similar demographics who has an average teacher. The student with the excellent teacher would also be 0.5 percent more likely to attend college." This is the power that vested, compassionate teachers can have on a student's life. While some of my students will say they like me and others will say the exact opposite, all my students would say that I care about them and care about their success. When a student feels that a person, especially a teacher, cares and believes in them, that student will strive to retain that faith others have in him/her.

I got ahead of myself and posted before I highlighted or captured...i'll have to experiment more closely with Diigo on my next post! I thought this article was interesting because it adds the community component to urban school reform. "Community-based organizations that deal with issues such as housing, health, and regeneration would profit from partnering with schools and working together to improve the lot and the education of children living in these areas as a means of benefiting both schools and the community." This intrigued me as it is a reminder if a child's basic needs are not being met (shelter, health, etc) then school is going to be on the back burner. This collaboration between school and community seems to be a piece to the reform puzzle.

Yes, it was implemented, but I am not sure how fully. Mayor Washington died while in office, and the plan was quite a radical departure from the way urban schools historically were - and still are - run. So, as you can imagine, it was maintained without fidelity (LSCs still exist, but to varying widely in their effectiveness and with much of their power stripped) and other critical parts of the plan were dismantled.

As a teacher in a Title I school, I often find it difficult to contact students' homes since so many students move around during the school year and some parents/guardians tend not to be very receptive. Nonetheless, some of the greatest successes I feel I have had during my two years of teaching have come from parent-teacher conferences that I have called and/or those informal phone calls I do when a student misses five days, begins to fail my class, or is disruptive. The article says "Engaging community groups with schools has the added benefit of helping teachers and other educators to better understand the communities and lifestyles of the children they teach, and thus to better adapt their style to meet their needs." I have formed positive working relationships with many of my students' families, which not only led to an improvement in the students' behavior, but also their academic performance. That old saying "It takes a village to raise a child" also applies to educating them as well.

Jill, I really enjoyed this article! It is an interesting perspective for me, an elementary teacher, who never gets a chance to witness the great things that are being done at the high school level. Like you, I think it's truly important for higher education discussions to begin earlier than high school...the earlier, the better. Students need to have the mentality that they CAN and WILL go to college because it is their educational right, despite any hardships they may have to face. Building excitement in school based on school spirit days (Represent Your Alma Mater Day) or field trips to see what is available can instill the excitement and motivation of higher education. Thanks for sharing!

Wow! Jill what a great program to be a part of. How do your students react to this experience? Are they open to asking questions? Do they show genuine interest and intrigue? Also, I agree that there needs to be a "YES I CAN" attitude. This takes more than just a teacher though. It takes a the school as a community to instill these ideas into students. By teaching students the possibilities and starting their intrigue in higher education earlier, I think there can be a change in mind-set. At the high school level, I see many of my ELL students doubt their abilities or chances of attending college, so they never allow that dream to come into their minds. With the right encouragement and guidance, this can change.

Great article Jill. Pike started a really neat college initiative this year that involved the elementary, middle and high schools. It involved teachers discussing colleges during academic advisory times, decorating classrooms and wearing college gear on certain days. Although I do not have college bound students in my classroom, we still decorated my door and I had several students come in my classroom asking about IU. I was able to share my experience with them. This initiative was able to provide students with a chance to talk with teachers about real life experiences. I don't know what they were doing at the elementary level, but I would be interested to see what activities took place, as I think early exposure is necessary. It would be worthwhile to also have parents involved at an early age, especially for students whose parents did not attend college.

The Key Learning Community is based upon the Theory of Multiple Intelligences developed by Dr. Howard Gardner of Harvard University. I visited Key during my undergraduate work. I am a huge fan of Howard Gardner.

I am also a fan of Dr. Howard Gardner. With my profession, I think it is so important to realize the whole-child and finding ways where all students can succeed. My high school friend did Teach for America with Kipp Indy. She fell in love with the school's mission and commitment to learning. After her 2 years with TFA, she stayed on and is now a coordinator for collegiate education.

I really appreciated what Ron Smith, the principal, said: "Children are naturally curious about the world and they have many ways of expressing what they know. They have questions of their own that should be taken seriously by the adults who surround them." I think this applies to all levels of learners. Curiosity and intrigue are so important as students grow academically. This is why probing questions were invented! Heuristic thinking and wonderments from our students allow them to explore and discover new meanings and gain new knowledge. I just really found myself connected to this statement and thought about the applications inside my own classroom.

Article abstract: This article explored "the personal and professional changes experienced by a teacher education faculty who embarked on a joint project relating to urban education. The faculty members committed to write book chapters applying their areas of expertise to the challenge of preparing teachers for urban schools." With a qualitative research design, the results showed a detailed description of the staff's "discoveries, thoughts, doubts, and reflections at three points during the project" The study's results revealed "an evolving perspective on urban education focusing upon understanding the lived experiences of the children" as a means of implementing meaningful education for these urban students.

I think what I'm starting to see is that the essence...is not developing recipes, quick fixes and a how-to-do-it book as much as it is to begin to talk about the need for understanding such issues as passion, resilience, compensatory kind of skills...I'm getting more to the point of talking about what a person takes into the environment...So if we try to just give our students a whole lot of tricks saying this will work and that will work I think we're setting them up for failure. So we've got to try to turn some of their attitude into philosophy and understanding of the urban setting. It's more knowledge and attitude than it is a skill. That's a change. That's not the way I was approaching it (ST, 11/6, pp. 1-2).

I agree that a lack of experiences in urban schools causes hesitation and confusion. I remember going to a school-wide urban education training when I first started teaching in my district. Having some experience with attending and student teaching in an urban school setting, I was astounded by the lack of knowledge of some of my peers. Most of them thought they would be able to build relationships with the students right away and demand their respect. As our student population changed and we gained experience, we became less hesitant and started brainstorming ways to involve our ever-changing community in order to develop better relationships.

This article contains information about reform efforts in IPS, special education reform initiatives, and examples of success for IPS.

After reading this article, did you find that the implementation and reform initiatives were working? Not having worked in Indianapolis, I cannot be an accurate judge of the influence these ideas of success are having on IPS. I was just wondering what your thoughts were regarding the reality of the changes and the effectiveness?

I think looking at the beginning numbers before they changed the schools around is interesting to what they are after. The graduation rate has gone down, but the middle school and elementary testing scores have gone up. This could mean that as these younger students get older the graduation rate will increase.

Their sway over policy and politics appears to be growing, especially at the state and local levels. A new generation of education advocacy groups has emerged to play a formidable political role in states and communities across the country.

Interesting article! I think that advocacy groups pushing for the interests of CHILDREN is something that has been long overdue to the reformation of urban education. Also, I read about Rhee in a different article, for anyone that is interested and wants any more background knowledge. Link is below: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1862444-1,00.html

I used the link to Indiana's Democrats for Education Reform and found information about a budget proposal for next year. They are discussing adding additional cost to states and districts that are already under economic stress! Democrats for Education Reform - Indiana: http://www.dfer.org/branches/in/

This is an interesting New York Times article on school resegregation. The reporter uses stats about the schools citywide and compares it to the situation at the charter school analyzed, before going into the experiences of individual teachers and students at the school to show some of the issues and complexities of urban schools that are segregated by race.

Its really amazing how when asked about a life changing experience one person's experience is getting a cat and another person can say seeing their cousin shot. It really shows that we all grow up in different situations and have completely different perspectives and definitions of things like "what a life changing experience is."