Skip to main content

Home/ Ethique à WIC 5/ Group items tagged rights

Rss Feed Group items tagged

Mira Marhaba

SparkNotes: Utilitarianism: Chapter 5: Of the Connection between Justice and Utility (P... - 1 views

  • Mill begins by trying to pin down the meaning of justice, by coming up with a list of those things that are commonly classified as just or unjust. First, it is considered unjust to deprive someone of his legal rights. However, this concept has exceptions. For example, a person may have legal rights he should not have--his rights may be the provision of a bad law. While people vary on whether bad laws can be justly disobeyed, all people agree that laws can be unjust. Therefore, law cannot be the ultimate standard of justice. A second form of injustice comes from depriving someone of something he has a moral right to possess. Third, it is considered just that a person receive what he "deserves," and unjust that he obtain something he doesn't deserve; people are thought to deserve good things if they have done right, and evil things if they have done wrong. A fourth form of injustice is to violate an agreement with someone or disappoint expectations that one knowingly nurtured. Fifth, it is considered unjust to show favoritism and preference in inappropriate circumstances. However, it is not generally necessary to be impartial; for example, one doesn't have to be impartial in the selection of friends. The claim is rather that a person should only be influenced by those considerations that should apply in a given circumstance. Finally, the idea of equality is seen by many to be a component of justice; some people may make an exception for the sake of expediency, however.
  •  
    This quote is a bit on the big side (understatement), but i highlighted it all to show the connection between utilitarianism and justice. It shows all the exceptions to some laws that may be made, and WHY they should be made. So basically it shows that just because there is a law, it doesn't mean that it is necessarily right.
  •  
    Legal does not equal moral. "Therefore, law cannot be the ultimate standard of justice. "
Nighat Ali

The Case for Legalized Prostitution - 1 views

shared by Nighat Ali on 20 Nov 11 - Cached
  • Recent research indicates that over one million women in the United States earn their living by full-time prostitution.
  • such prohibitions violate one's most basic and inherent rights. Prostitution is the voluntary sale (or rental) of a labor service. Individuals own their own bodies and their own labor services and have the absolute right to decide how those labor services should be used.
  • such prohibitions violate one's most basic and inherent rights. Prostitution is the voluntary sale (or rental) of a labor service. Individuals own their own bodies and their own labor services and have the absolute right to decide how those labor services should be used.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • Prostitution may be the world's oldest profession, and laws prohibiting prostitution may well be the oldest example of government regulation and government (sex) discrimination. In a free society, however, all such laws are inappropriate because they violate the basic rights and liberties of the individuals involved.
  •  
    Prostitution s'agit comme une choix d'emploi. C'Est une moyen pour les femmes de recevoir de l'argent. En plus de ceci, elle créés de l'injustice vers les personnes qui aiment cette profession.
Matthew Rodin

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights - 0 views

shared by Matthew Rodin on 31 Oct 11 - Cached
  • Article 1. All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.
  • Article 5. No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
  • Article 18. Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.
  •  
    La déclaration des droits humaines des Nations Unis
Giuliano Musacchio

pursuit of happiness - Legal Definition - 0 views

    • Giuliano Musacchio
       
      this is a legal definition, that proves that one can pursue any actions that will please them as long as it does not affect others
  • An inalienable right enumerated in the Declaration of Independence, in addition to life and liberty; the right to pursue any legal activity as long as it does not infringe on the rights of others.
Matthew Rodin

Animal Experimentation: Debatabase - Debate Topics and Debate Motions - 4 views

  • Animals have the right to be treated as beings of value in themselves
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      Encore une fois, la valeur de l'égalité même entre des espèces différentes!
  • the end of cruelty to animals
  • animals are not routinely treated well by animal experimenters
  • ...12 more annotations...
  • millions of animals die each year in experiments, others are often not adequately anaesthetised and are abused by handlers and experimenters.
  • ew breakthroughs have been made as a result of animal experimentatio
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      Ca montre que l'expérimentation animale produit une pourcentage minimale de succès!
  • There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing,
  • Human beings share about 99% of their genes with chimpanzees and only slightly fewer with other monkeys. As a result, the reactions of these creatures are a very good guide to possible reactions of human patients. Even lower down the scale, other animals share the same basic physiology with humans. Furthermore, it would be immoral to risk the life of a human being when a medicine or procedure could instead be tested on a non-human animal. In fact, most animal experiments are done on animals that are nothing like hum
  • Scientifically, as well as morally, most animal experimentation is to be rejected - the reaction of a mouse to a substance is no guide to human reactions
  • The advent of genetic technologies has made possible all sorts of new and horrific acts of animal exploitation
  • t is only acceptable to test human medicines on human beings if they give their consent. Non-human animals are never able to give such consent
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "Animals have the right to be treated as beings of value in themselves" -L'égalité!!!! C'est une bonne valeur pour l'argumentation. Besoin de plus de statistiques...
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "Millions of animals die each year in experiments, others are often not adequately anaesthetised and are abused by handlers and experimenters" -C'est LE point le plus concrète du débat CONTRE l'expérimentation animale. Besoin de faits avec sources, par contre.
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "The advent of genetic technologies has made possible all sorts of new and horrific acts of animal exploitation" -Le fait que la technologie évolue continuellement est un bon point pour nous car il y a plusieurs méthodes ou les animaux ne doivent pas être mal traités!
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing." -Le fait qu'il y a une très grand nombre de fautes dans l'expérimentation animale est un argument qui va caser tous ceux de l'autre équipe. Si vous voulez tester des médicament POUR les humains, tester-les SUR les humains, et non pas sur d'autres espèces qui vont réagir différemment!
  • There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing,
  •  
    C'est une bonne outil pour les deux équipes qui sont en débat contre ou pour l'expérimentation animale.
Nighat Ali

Legalize Prostitution - 0 views

  • Laws against prostitution violate Americans' fundamental rights of individual liberty and personal privacy. Thomas Jefferson and other founders of the U.S. envisioned a society where people can live without interference from government, provided they don't harm others
    • Nighat Ali
       
      Si nous vivons dans une société libre, pouquoi la prostitution n'est pas légal? On comprend tous que lorsqu'on rend quelque chose de illégal c'est lorsque se chose cause du mal au société, mais la prostitution ne cause aucun mal à la société donc pourquoi on ne le rends pas légal?
Hagit Malikin

Torture uses the body against the soul. It is illegal and dumb | Charles Guthrie - Time... - 0 views

  • The Geneva Conventions and the UN Convention Against Torture, firewalls for our collective humanity, expressly forbid it. It is prohibited without qualification in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights - a document signed by people from every corner and culture of the Earth who had survived the suffering of both world wars, the horrors of fascism, and the evil of the Holocaust. They understood well that global humanitarian norms and a rules-based world order are in all our interests
    • Hagit Malikin
       
      people signed a document saying that torture is not permitted for ny reason. some people went through holocaust, wars and still they dont accept torture
  •  
    people signed a document agreeing that torture is wrong even after being faced with wars, holocausts etc
Nighat Ali

Defending Christmas: It's "Merry Christmas," not "Happy Holidays" |... - 2 views

    • Nighat Ali
       
      Je trove que cette point de vue de l'auteure est très intéressant...
  • It's that time of year again - the buildup to the holiday whose name so many people are afraid to say. "Merry Christmas." Why do these two words offend so many people? Why is this greeting such a big problem? Why are their retail stores that insist their employees say "Happy Holidays"? Of course, some have even dropped the 's', and wish people a "Happy Holiday." What holiday are they talking about? Why can't they just say it!? Why are there so many offices that are afraid to have a "Christmas" party? Why are public schools forbidden to utter the word "Christmas" and, in some cases, not allowed to even have red and green decorations or visits from Santa Claus? What's the problem with Christmas? In truth, there should be NO problem with Christmas - and there should be no problem , thankfully, some retail stores like Wal-Mart are wising up to this fact.
  • tmas" party? Why are public schools forbidden to utter the word "Christmas" and, in some cases,
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • While the United States is officially and culturally committed to religious freedom, the overwhelming majority of the American people respect Christmas as it has traditionally been understood and observed. Here are some facts to prove this: According to the well-known polling firm Zogby, 95% of Americans are NOT offended when they hear "Merry Christmas" and over half are "bothered" by the greeting "Happy Holidays." A FOXNEWS poll in 2005 suggests that 95% of Americans celebrate Christmas - that's "Christmas" specifically as in the holiday on December 25 Another FOXNEWS poll that same year said that 83% of respondents believed nativity scenes were appropriate for public propertyA 2004 Newsweek poll revealed that 79% of Americans believe in the virgin birth of Jesus Christ as depicted in the BibleNinety percent of respondents to a 2000 Gallup poll affirmed the birth of Jesus Christ as the purpose of Christmas
  • This author will grant that it's unethical and socially wrong to deliberately provoke and offend someone who is of a different faith. But this does not mean - nor should it mean - that we have to censor out any public, visible displays of Christmas for the comfort of the few who might be offended. The First Amendment guarantees the free exercise of religion. It does NOT - and read this carefully - it does NOT guarantee one the right to NOT be offended. It does NOT guarantee the right of one to be free of any social discomfort.
Mira Marhaba

A 20th Century Habit - 0 views

  • The twenty years from 1920 to 1940 saw a tripling in consumption with 182 billion cigarettes sold for a per capita number of 1,976.  Not coincidentally these twenty years saw the explosive growth of the new entertainment medium, the movies.  It was a rare move produced in those days that did not have smoking on screen.  WWII created another upsurge in smoking, as millions of GIs picked up the habit to temper the boredom and stress of combat. The 1945 numbers jumped to 341 billion and 3,449 per capita, or roughly half a pack a day for every person over the age of 18.
  •  
    These statistics are just to prove that: 1) just because a majority is voting, most certainly does NOT mean that they are right. they could be completely wrong (as they were about the smoking before the 1930's) 2) even if the majority KNOWS that what theyre voting for or doing is bad, they may CONTINUE TO DO IT ANYWAY
Camil Darwiche

La religion dans les écoles - 0 views

  • However, as long as the practicing of the religion doesn't hurt or endanger anyone, there is no reason to believe that this goes against the rights of the other student or should be banned from school. It
  • religious clubs of many types can all exist in one school at one time. This allows students to meet other students with similar backgrounds, and similar interests. It strengthens the student population and provides additional avenues for friendships.
    • Camil Darwiche
       
      C'est un très bon argument car ça démontre que que la religion dans les écoles est bénéficielle. Ça prouve que les élèves qui y participent peuvent se rencontrer et devenir amies. C'est une bonne façon d'améliorer la vie sociale des élèves. 
  •  
    Ce site web est très bon pour les deux équipes puisqu'il a des arguments pour et contre.
Mira Marhaba

Should prostitution be legal? - Prostitution - ProCon.org - 0 views

  • "One cannot support the reduction of AIDS infections and support legal prostitution at the same time. Prostitution remains one of the leading vectors for AIDS infection. This is true in the case of both legal and illegal prostitution... Prostitutes, because of their many partners, have a greatly increased risk of exposure to HIV. They are likewise able to spread HIV to many other partners...
    • Mira Marhaba
       
      Dans notre société, on essaie de reduire le sida et tous les autres "STD". En légalisant la prostitution, on va surement élever les taux de STD.
  • There are a multitude of studies to show the high level of abuse that prostitutes suffer. Women are literally bought and sold as property. The incidence of drug addiction is high among women, partially explaining why they became prostitutes to begin with. The argument for legalization goes something like this. Prostitution will happen anyway but legalization and regulation will help stem the abuses. The argument has 50,000 foot appeal. Using the same logic, slavery (which still exists in many places) should be legalized so underground slaves can be given some measure of human rights. The fact that the ACLU and the bevy of left-wing international groups don't argue for the legalization of slavery shows the logical inconsistency of their position. Further, the legalization of abortion has shown that it lead to a radical increase in abortion. The legalization will lead to an untold number of women being forced into sex slavery. Make no mistake, women will be forced into commercial sex work in greater numbers if it were legalized."
    • Mira Marhaba
       
      Les femmes vont faire face a une grande quantité d'abus. Le plus qu'on a de prostitution, le plus qu'on va avoir d'abus de femmes.
  • Legalized prostitution creates the same problems that legalized marijuana does. While prostitution is legal, forced prostitution is not. The latter occurs, and the new German law unintentionally makes it harder to hunt down human traffickers, especially from Eastern Europe and Africa. Similarly, it is harder to combat under-aged prostitution. With legalized marijuana and prostitution, Amsterdam became a magnet for human traffickers, drug traders and petty criminals. This is not the world legalization’s proponents envisioned, but it happened."
    • Mira Marhaba
       
      ABUS!! Ca va être beaucoup plus difficile de trouver des criminels (qui forcent des autres a se prostituer) si on a cette loi
Teen Turtle

Celebrating Christmas in Public - 4 views

  • The question: How can we celebrate our diversity of holiday celebrations? How can we enjoy and magnify this aspect of American greatness? Bill Press's answer is that, among other things, we should say "Happy Holidays" rather than "Merry Christmas" when we're in diverse company. (I assume Press thinks it's okay for me to say "Merry Christmas" to other Christians.) Is he right? Does this reflect and celebrate our diversity?
    • Teen Turtle
       
      Cet article offre un point de vue non-religieux sur la célébration national de certaines fête. Il remet aussi en question ce qu'est réelement la diversité culturelle.
  • So, "Happy Holidays" really isn't so much a matter of celebrating diversity as it is a means to squelch diversity. It masks and diminishes the genuine variety of cultures in America. One might argue that genuine religious diversity ought to ignored or hidden away. But please don't try to fool me with a plea to diversity if you're going to argue for non-specific sameness.
1 - 12 of 12
Showing 20 items per page