Skip to main content

Home/ Ethique à WIC 5/ Group items tagged debate

Rss Feed Group items tagged

vanessa parent

The great Canadian euthanasia debate - The Globe and Mail - 1 views

    • vanessa parent
       
      This site really explains the entire topic of Euthanasia giving the different approaches to it, it helps us understand the topic we are debating which is extremely imporant. And it is from a credible site "TheGlobeAndMail.com 
Matthew Rodin

Animal Experimentation: Debatabase - Debate Topics and Debate Motions - 4 views

  • Animals have the right to be treated as beings of value in themselves
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      Encore une fois, la valeur de l'égalité même entre des espèces différentes!
  • the end of cruelty to animals
  • animals are not routinely treated well by animal experimenters
  • ...12 more annotations...
  • millions of animals die each year in experiments, others are often not adequately anaesthetised and are abused by handlers and experimenters.
  • ew breakthroughs have been made as a result of animal experimentatio
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      Ca montre que l'expérimentation animale produit une pourcentage minimale de succès!
  • There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing,
  • Human beings share about 99% of their genes with chimpanzees and only slightly fewer with other monkeys. As a result, the reactions of these creatures are a very good guide to possible reactions of human patients. Even lower down the scale, other animals share the same basic physiology with humans. Furthermore, it would be immoral to risk the life of a human being when a medicine or procedure could instead be tested on a non-human animal. In fact, most animal experiments are done on animals that are nothing like hum
  • Scientifically, as well as morally, most animal experimentation is to be rejected - the reaction of a mouse to a substance is no guide to human reactions
  • The advent of genetic technologies has made possible all sorts of new and horrific acts of animal exploitation
  • t is only acceptable to test human medicines on human beings if they give their consent. Non-human animals are never able to give such consent
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "Animals have the right to be treated as beings of value in themselves" -L'égalité!!!! C'est une bonne valeur pour l'argumentation. Besoin de plus de statistiques...
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "Millions of animals die each year in experiments, others are often not adequately anaesthetised and are abused by handlers and experimenters" -C'est LE point le plus concrète du débat CONTRE l'expérimentation animale. Besoin de faits avec sources, par contre.
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "The advent of genetic technologies has made possible all sorts of new and horrific acts of animal exploitation" -Le fait que la technologie évolue continuellement est un bon point pour nous car il y a plusieurs méthodes ou les animaux ne doivent pas être mal traités!
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      "There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing." -Le fait qu'il y a une très grand nombre de fautes dans l'expérimentation animale est un argument qui va caser tous ceux de l'autre équipe. Si vous voulez tester des médicament POUR les humains, tester-les SUR les humains, et non pas sur d'autres espèces qui vont réagir différemment!
  • There has been a catalogue of errors and failures in animal testing,
  •  
    C'est une bonne outil pour les deux équipes qui sont en débat contre ou pour l'expérimentation animale.
Elior Yona

Debate at Debate.org - 1 views

shared by Elior Yona on 04 Oct 11 - Cached
Matthew Rodin

Torture in Interrogation: Debatabase - Debate Topics and Debate Motions - 3 views

  • he Geneva Conventions do not apply to interrogation of terrorists and suspected terrorists held by U.S. soldiers because they are not prisoners of war. They are illegal, enemy combatants, not subject to such protection.
    • Matthew Rodin
       
      The fact that the Geneva Conventions do not apply in the interrogation of terrorists is a big PRO!
  •  
    C'est un site web qui bénéfit les deux groupes. Un liste de pour et contres.
vanessa parent

Euthanasia: the debate continues - 1 views

    • vanessa parent
       
      This site shows great pointers and arguments for the debate for the legalization of Euthanasia. 
  •  
    This site is dubious. Can you tell who publishes it?
anonymous

Merry Christmas or Happy Holidays? : Debatabase - Debate Topics and Debate Motions - 2 views

  • Christmas has no religious meaning for people who do not share a Christian background
  • We should be more sensitive to the feelings of those around us and keep any Christian celebration for family and church.
  • “Happy Holidays” is a much more appropriate greeting
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • it is wrong to send cards that assume all of their employees have a Christian faith and wish to share it
    • anonymous
       
      We can use the Cons to rebut againt the other team
  •  
    Cette site a des argument pour les deux côté. Alors on peut l'utiliser pour notre aventage.
Daryl Bambic

Marc Thiessen: Is Torture Necessary? - Law and Ethics - Browse - Big Ideas - ABC TV - 2 views

    • Daryl Bambic
       
      this is useful for some students preparing for the debate on November 1st.
Camil Darwiche

La religion dans les écoles - 0 views

  • However, as long as the practicing of the religion doesn't hurt or endanger anyone, there is no reason to believe that this goes against the rights of the other student or should be banned from school. It
  • religious clubs of many types can all exist in one school at one time. This allows students to meet other students with similar backgrounds, and similar interests. It strengthens the student population and provides additional avenues for friendships.
    • Camil Darwiche
       
      C'est un très bon argument car ça démontre que que la religion dans les écoles est bénéficielle. Ça prouve que les élèves qui y participent peuvent se rencontrer et devenir amies. C'est une bonne façon d'améliorer la vie sociale des élèves. 
  •  
    Ce site web est très bon pour les deux équipes puisqu'il a des arguments pour et contre.
naomi suissa

Making a Case for Euthanasia - TIME - 0 views

  • The 52- year-old Dijon schoolteacher suffers from a rare disease that has left her disfigured by facial tumors, which will also damage her brain over time and eventually kill her.
    • naomi suissa
       
      Pour moi, les mots clés dans cette citation son "eventually kill her". Elles montrent la sévérité du cas de Chantal Sebire et nous aide a comprendre pourquoi elle demande que la loi de l'euthanasie soit ré-évaluée.
  • Her death will come, they say, after a long coma that will reduce her to being nothing but an inanimate burden on her family.
    • naomi suissa
       
      Est-ce que c'est meilleure de la laisser vivre en souffrant au point qu'elle sera considérée comme fardeau inanimé, ou respecter ses vœux de mourir avec de la paix et de la dignité?
  • "when I hear debates on euthanasia, I tell myself that while I respect the principles, the convictions, at the bottom of my heart I still say there are limits to the suffering that can be imposed on a human."
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • "It's hard for my children to imagine me going away there," Sebire explains, "but I can't take this anymore."
    • naomi suissa
       
      Elle est une mère de 3 enfants et elle veut quand même être libérée de sa vie. Pourquoi devrait-on la forcer de vivre avec ses circonstances?
  •  
    Chantal Sebire- une femme de 52 ans qui souffre d'une maladie rare esthioneuroblastoma. Elle veut que la loi contre l'euthanasie soit ré-évaluée dans son cas. Cette article nous aide à comprendre sa vie dure et sa perspective sur sa situation.
Elior Yona

Animal Testing Pros - 0 views

    • Elior Yona
       
      we can use this sentence as an example to diseases that have been cured with the help of animal testing.
  • helped in the refinement of procedures
  • But it usually starts to make more sense when someone in the family or you yourself start suffering from a life-threatening disease.
  • ...1 more annotation...
    • Elior Yona
       
      we can use the example with the family members for the rebuttal.
naomi suissa

Can the Pursuit of Happiness Make You Unhappy? « peer-reviewed by my neurons - 0 views

  • paradoxical effects
    • naomi suissa
       
      Those who expect to reach a certain level of happiness rarely reach that goal because this level of happiness often has standards that are much too high
  • failed to achieve your goal of being happy
  • negative effects of valuing happiness are most likely to occur in situations where people feel they should be happy
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • The researchers hypothesized that although there would be no differences among those who watched the sad clip, the participants watching the happy clip who valued happiness would be less happy than those who did not value happiness. In the end, this is exactly what happened.
    • naomi suissa
       
      After this study, the researchers came to the exact conclusion that they were expecting!!
    • naomi suissa
       
      I consider this site useful because the author is elaborating on my side of the debate and giving me hints on how I could convince my opponent that I truly believe that the pursuit of happiness makes you unhappy 
  •  
    Article by Eric Horow; his perspective of the pursuit of happiness
  •  
    Interesting blog and author...not the most credible for your cause but still interesting.
Hagit Malikin

BBC - Ethics - Torture: Why is torture wrong? - 1 views

  • Torture is an ineffective interrogation tool It may well produce false information because under torture a prisoner will eventually say anything to stop the pain - regardless of whether it is true
    • Hagit Malikin
       
      this is a good point when debating the point of torturing when it comes to getting info
1 - 12 of 12
Showing 20 items per page