Dr. Andrew Feenberg: Ten Paradoxes of Technology - YouTube - 7 views
-
Jeremy Kemp on 27 Aug 12"Dr. Andrew Feenberg: Ten Paradoxes of Technology"
-
B Bernheim on 01 Sep 12I am not sure I agree with his truth in these paradoxes. Starting with his notion that a non-speaking human is less than human to his notion that workers/guilds did not influence change in manufacturing technologies speak to his belief that his thoughts are the most accurate, in my opinon. Many changes in manufacturing are the direct result of a worker creating either something that did a task in less time and better/safer to creating a product to do a job that did not exist previously. Those things should and will occur in technology moving forward. I had to watch this a couple of times as his presentation tone and expressions or lack thereof made following him challenging to me. The Democratic Paradox resonated the most with me as he discussed the relationship of technology to society to Escher's Drawing Hand. Paraphrasing what I think he was saying - "What was originally created in a military computer lab does not really resemble the technological environment we have today and it is hard to distinguish who is creating what at this point as society and technology merge. Unless we study technology from a historical prospective, we will not know the reasons for why things are a certain way in years to come." I do not see a separation in that thought from any other in a need for an intellectual society to study its own history in order to prevent making similar mistakes in the future.