Dr. Brian Day extols the benefits of a (two-tier) hybrid health system - part publicly funded and part private, for-profit. Besides giving people more choice of health servers, he suggests it would also benefit the public health sector by reducing waiting times for surgeries and procedures.
For this system to work, however, the private sector must out-perform the public sector and offer reduced waiting times. Otherwise, why pay for a privately performed operation when one could get the same procedure done at no extra cost in the public sector?
This can only happen if private clinics and hospitals employ more resources per patient than the public sector. For every patient who switches to private care, more resources are also switched. We already witness this in B.C., where doctors, nurses, lab technicians, not to mention health managers and receptionists, are attracted by higher salaries offered in private clinics. We are starting to suffer acute labour shortages in the public health sector, leading to even longer waiting lists. A private health sector, rather than reducing waiting lists, contributes to waiting lists. The solution is clear: it is not to encourage the growth of the private health sector but instead for government to increase funding of the public health sector.
Alan Morris
Economist, Economics Department, Capilano University