Abstract
The World Health Report launched the Health Workforce Decade (2006-2015),
with high priority given for countries to develop effective workforce strategies
including healthy workplaces for health workers. Evidence shows that healthy
workplaces improve recruitment and retention, workers' health and well-being,
quality of care and patient safety, organizational performance and societal
outcomes. Over the past few years, healthy workplace issues in Canada have been
on the agenda of many governments and employers.
The purpose of this paper is to provide a progress update, using different
data-collection approaches, on knowledge transfer and uptake of research
evidence in policy and practice, including the next steps for the healthy
workplace agenda in Canada. The objectives of this paper are (1) to summarize
the current healthy workplace initiatives that are currently under way in
Canada; (2) to synthesize what has been done in reality to determine how far the
healthy workplace agenda has progressed from the perspectives of research,
policy and practice; and (3) to outline the next steps for moving forward with
the healthy workplace agenda to achieve its ultimate objectives. Some of the key
questions discussed in this paper are as follows: Has the existing evidence on
the benefits of healthy workplaces resulted in policy change? If so, how and to
what extent? Have the existing policy initiatives resulted in healthier
workplaces for healthcare workers? Are there indications that healthcare
workers, particularly at the front line, are experiencing better working
conditions?
While there has been significant progress in bringing policy changes as a
result of research evidence, our synthesis suggests that more work is needed to
ensure that existing policy initiatives bring effective changes to the
workplace. In this paper, we outline the next steps for research, policy and
practice that are required to help the healthy workplace agenda achieve its
ultimate objectives.
The early decades of the 21st century belong to health human resources (HHR).
The World Health Report (World Health Organization [WHO] 2006) launched the
Health Workforce Decade (2006-2015), with high priority given for countries to
develop effective workforce strategies that include three core elements:
improving recruitment, helping the existing workforce to perform better and
slowing the rate at which workers leave the health workforce. In this recent
report, retaining high-quality healthcare workers is discussed as a major
strategic issue for healthcare systems and employers, and improving workplaces
as a key strategy for achieving this goal.
The workplace can act as either a push or pull factor for HHR. Heavy
workloads, excessive overtime, inflexible scheduling, safety hazards, poor
management and few opportunities for leadership and professional development are
among the push factors that result in poor recruitment and retention of HHR.
Evidence shows that healthy workplaces improve recruitment and retention,
workers' health and well-being, quality of care and patient safety,
organizational performance and societal outcomes.
What are healthy workplaces? Based on existing definitions, there is not yet
a standardized and comprehensive definition of healthy workplaces. In this
paper, we define healthy workplaces as mechanisms, programs, policies,
initiatives, actions and practices that are in place to provide the health
workforce with physical, mental, psychosocial and organizational conditions
that, in return, contribute to improved workers' health and well-being, quality
of care and patient safety, organizational performance and societal outcomes
(Griffin et al. 2006).
Over the past few years, healthy workplace issues in Canada have been on the
agenda of many governments and stakeholder organizations. Nationally and
internationally, robust evidence has been accumulated on the impact of healthy
workplaces on workers' health and well-being, quality of care, patient safety,
organizational performance and societal outcomes. This evidence has provided
guidance for governments and employers in terms of what should be done to make
the workplace healthier for healthcare workers. Across Canada, many initiatives
to improve the working conditions for HHR are currently under way, but the
continuing concerns suggest that barriers remain. An assessment of the progress
to date is necessary in order to inform the next steps for research, policy and
practice.