Skip to main content

Home/ Public Philosophy/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by André de Avillez

Contents contributed and discussions participated by André de Avillez

1More

Article withdrawal | Elsevier - 0 views

  •  
    policies for retracting/withdrawing published articles
1More

PLOS Computational Biology: A Peer-Reviewed Open-Access Journal - 0 views

  •  
    Guidelines for public commenting on articles at PLOS computational biology
1More

PLOS Computational Biology: A Peer-Reviewed Open-Access Journal - 0 views

  •  
    Reviewer guidelines for PLOS computational biology
1More

PLOS Medicine: A Peer-Reviewed Open-Access Journal - 0 views

  •  
    General Policies for PLOS journals
1More

Chapter 2. Communication-specific guidelines - 0 views

  •  
    Good resource for policies on community communication
19More

Art and Truth after Plato // Reviews // Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews // University ... - 4 views

    • André de Avillez
       
      Overview of target project.  Seems like one the author would endorse, but it's impossible to know without asking the author, and difficult to guess without having read the work being reviewed.
  • hat 'long ago'
    • André de Avillez
       
      Derisive tone
  • story
    • André de Avillez
       
      Referring to the content of the book as a story rather than as a historical overview implies that the work lacks academic legitimacy
  • ...6 more annotations...
  • 'Middle Ages'
    • André de Avillez
       
      The use of scare quotes here, and the qualifiers that follow, imply a veiled criticism. It seems that criticisms must be open in order to be collegial, for otherwise they imply that the target's author is too dimwitted to grasp a meaning which is plainly grasped by the reviewer and the audience.
  • even the briefest survey would show, I think, that 'aesthetic cognitivism', as it is increasingly referred to, is not only widely discussed, but alive and wel
    • André de Avillez
       
      Very critical language, framing a serious critique.  Yet it seems that the obvious has not been stated: the author was too focused on the continental tradition, and the reviewer was largely unfamiliar with that tradition (so much so that he saw the "excursion" into marxist aesthetics as unusual)
  • For example, he uses the expressions 'art and truth' and 'art and cognition' more or less interchangeably. But the conflation of 'truth' and 'cognition' confounds many of the issues he want to discuss, because there are important dimensions to cognition other than truth
    • André de Avillez
       
      Criticism of the target, attempted at the target's own terms.
  • with which contemporary aesthetics is concerned.
    • André de Avillez
       
      One has to worry here of how the discipline is being defined.  Does analytic philosophy have dominance over the field?
  • In doing so he ranges very widely, and considers many writers who get scant attention nowadays, devoting a whole chapter to 'Marx, Marxism, and Aesthetic Realism', for instance.
    • André de Avillez
       
      Praise for target of review
  • n any event, though the chapter on 'Christian Platonic and Anti-Platonic Art' is not noticeably shorter than the others, it does not have a key role in the philosophical trajectory that Rockmore is tracing.
    • André de Avillez
       
      Implies that the chapter is unnecessary, and does not attempt to see why it would have been left in.  Even if a philosophical aesthetics is not present in this long period, the author may have chosen to discuss it for the sake of completeness, and to show to what extent a philosophy of art/ aesthetics existed in the middle ages.
  •  
    A negative review which labors to see the merits in the target
1More

The Weirdness of Being: Heidegger's Unheard Answer to the Seinsfrage // Reviews // Notr... - 5 views

  •  
    Interesting review sample. Critical of the target's overall philosophical project.
1More

Why children should study philosophy - 0 views

  •  
    This might be interesting in connection with outreach programs like the one Michael Burrows is running.
2More

Unionize College Football | Jacobin - 0 views

  • The unionization campaign at Northwestern is no doubt exciting. That any group of people in their late-teens and early-twenties, football players or otherwise, thought to address their workplace grievances through organizing is, in this rabidly anti-union place and time, nothing short of remarkable. If they succeed (which is still far from certain), their victory could reverberate across the intercollegiate athletic world, transforming the NCAA in the process. And, not inconsequentially, they could pave the road for organizing advances by graduate students, medical residents, and many others who work for the same institution that bestows their degrees or credentials.
  •  
    Piece on the unionization efforts by Northwestern University's football team.
1More

Don't fear the patriarchy, girls. Just keep your knickers on - 0 views

  •  
    Feminist (feminist-leaning) analysis of a viral conservative video promoting an economy of sex
1More

getting past emotional truth | Fredrik deBoer - 0 views

  •  
    Critique of posts by frustrated adjuncts, pointing out that exaggerations are counter productive.
17More

The Work of Public Work | Jacobin - 2 views

  • At the same time, I want to hold Robin accountable to his desire for a “materialist analysis of the relationship between politics, economics, and culture.”
  • I think he wrongly characterizes the conditions under which many of these young academics are writing
  • The risk of being a public intellectual, he posits, comes from the fact that these scholars are taking time away from their academic writing
  • ...13 more annotations...
  • The workload of academics has increased exponentially in recent years, as has been well-documented
  • I have found that writing for popular audiences is not solely an internal passion, but has actually become an external demand of young scholars, another metric by which their job application or tenure-file is evaluated.
  • The problem is that Robin goes on to romanticize the lives of young scholar-writers, saying that their work arises from intrinsic desires, whose realization is made possible by new technology:
  • Young scholars are compelled to transform themselves into academic entrepreneurs, creating a brand that they promote through their blogs, tweets, and online profiles.
  • The swelling workloads of academics are indicative of the micropolitics of neoliberalism
  • The mantra of “publishing early and often” has intensified, especially in a tight job market. As tenured horizons grow grimmer, new scholars must do anything they can to stand out above a crowd of over-achievers. Publish early, publish often — and now, publish online.
  • Consider the website Academia.edu
  • But the site also exemplifies the quantification of the productive self, with each profile displaying the number of views, article downloads, and followers for each academic.
  • It’s no wonder that I’ve also seen a growing number of colleagues (myself included) add a “Public Scholarship” section to their CVs
  • The labor of public intellectualism is more than a political project, or even a charitable effort of self-expression — it’s another manifestation of exploitation
  • As a result, young academics trying to keep up with new media are writing, reading blogs and engaging in Twitter wars during lunch breaks, between teaching commitments, and well into the night.
  • To meet the demands of academic capitalism, there’s now even less of a chance of ever clocking out.
  • Yes, let us praise the young writers whose voices are being seen and heard across the blogosphere, and luxuriate in the possibilities of transcending the borders of the Ivory Tower. But let us not forget that writing, even on the Internet, and even for the “public good,” is still work. And whenever we’re encouraged to do more work, we should be a bit wary.
  •  
    A response to Corey Robin's response to Kristof's article, raising troubling concerns regarding the commodification of public scholarship.  Seems worth amplifying, in conjunction with the critiques of Kristof's piece or on its own.
1More

Digital Distractions: Pokemon and the Challenges of Collaboration - ProfHacker - Blogs ... - 0 views

  •  
    Short post reflecting on the challenges of digital collaboration, as exemplified in a large-scale collaborative video-game
1More

Toxicity: The True Story of Mainstream Feminism's Violent Gatekeepers | - 0 views

  •  
    Article arguing that concepts like "toxicity" and "politics of reponsibility" reflect white priviledge amongst some feminists
13More

The rise of Indigenous art speaks volumes about class in Australia - 0 views

  • The great story of recent Australian art has been the resurgence of Indigenous culture and its recognition as a major art form. But in a country increasingly divided by class and wealth, the rise of Indigenous art has had consequences undreamed of by those who first projected it onto the international exhibiting stage.
  • The continuing success of both traditional and western influenced art forms has led to one of the great paradoxes in Australian culture. At a time when art schools have subjugated themselves to the metrics-driven culture of the modern university system, when creative courses are more and more dominated by the children of privilege, some of the most interesting students and graduates are Indigenous.
  • Because Indigenous students were seen as a special case they managed to avoid the metrification of merit.
  • ...9 more annotations...
  • Not all Indigenous art students become artists. Some use the project-management skills inherent in making any creative endeavour to move onwards and upwards elsewhere
  • But because there are so many successful Indigenous artists, art remains both readily understood as a pathway out of poverty and a way to argue the cause
  • The poor see things differently
  • In the distant past, when tertiary study was less formalised, less measured than today, visually-talented working-class kids often gravitated to art schools.
  • n Australia the sense of freedom to choose a career seems to have been lost at about the same time as the introduction of HECS in 1989
  • There is a disconnect between the class of people who make and administer the rules and the lived experience of the many. Those who run the world see debt as a tool, a means to a well-considered end, a way to access working capital, a pathway to future wealth.
  • The children of the wealthy, who now dominate undergraduate arts education, know that mainstream culture belongs to them. There is no message of self-belief presented to those working-class students who may wish to take their art further because it was the one school subject that made sense to them.
  • my parents were not prepared to be guarantors for me to take a teaching scholarship
  • Accelerating divisions of class and wealth have seen a dramatic reduction in the number of bright, edgy students from the unfashionable suburbs studying the arts
  •  
    Article on the impact of a metrics-based university curriculum on arts programs in Australia, which is used to explain the disproportionate success of indigenous students, who are exempt from most metrics at the time of admission.
9More

The rise of morality politics in Africa: Talk is cheap and dangerous, but wins votes - 0 views

  • Legislating morality, unlike improving social services like health and education, is nearly costless for politicians. It is also extremely popular
  • In addition to winning votes, however, laws such as the criminalization of homosexuality can also be used opportunistically against both the public and political opposition
  • The anti-homosexuality bill reflects popular sentiment in Uganda, where 90 percent of respondents said that homosexuality was “never justified,
  • ...4 more annotations...
  • Recent “moral” legislation extends beyond homosexuality, however, and focusing on the salience of LGBT issues may obscure other arenas in which moral dictates are being employed for political purposes.
  • Legislating morality may seem odd in a country where more than three quarters of survey respondents believe “some of” or “most of” parliamentarians are corrupt, according to Afrobarometer data, but perhaps it is precisely because of their credibility deficit that politicians are employing moral dictates as a nearly costless alternative to delivering the goods and services that are so badly needed.
  • these laws can also be easily converted into tools for political witch hunts
  • In countries where mob justice is a common replacement for weak or non-existent law enforcement, these laws give way to everyday opportunism.
  •  
    Article on the current trend of legislating morality, and the side effects of such laws
  •  
    Might be a good one to amplify in relation to this article by Britt Holbrook and Adam Briggle: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/23299460.2014.882554#.UwzwEXVdXC1
1 - 20 of 46 Next › Last »
Showing 20 items per page