In Fargo, we defined gross negligence as "`more than ordinary inadvertence or inattention, but less perhaps than conscious indifference to the consequences.'" Fargo, 857 F.2d at 641 (quoting W. Page Keeton et al., Prosser and Keeton on the Law of Torts S 34, at 212 (5th ed. 1984)). We also noted that an officer's state of mind is not an issue in a claim based on gross negligence, "although the contrary may be true where the claim involves recklessness." Id. at 642. Although we declined to decide whether an innocent state of mind would negate recklessness or "whether recklessness may be presumed conclusively from conduct," we did note that recklessness and deliberate indifference are equivalent in the sense that they both generally refer to conduct involving "a `conscious disregard' of public safety." Id. at 642 n.7. We also said that, "where state officials have notice of the possibility of harm, `negligence can rise to the level of deliberate indifference to or reckless disregard for' the victim." Id. (quoting Davidson v. Cannon,
474 U.S. 344, 357
(1986) (Blackmun, J., dissenting)). Because we concluded that a triable issue of fact remained as to whether the police officer's conduct might have been grossly negligent, we found it unnecessary to determine whether the officer's conduct might have risen to the more culpable standard of recklessness. Id. at 643
Nye Frank on 09 Apr 09Sign In | Register | Newsletters Subscribe | e-Edition | Home Delivery | Mobile | Mobile Alerts | RSS HOME NEWS breaking news obituaries crime health science earthquakes politics nation / world ap headlines special reports education traffic weather weird news BUSINESS real estate green energy special reports financial markets personal finance venture capital drive / automotive data base press releases TECH news opinion sectors companies personal tech SPORTS 49ers raiders giants a's sharks warriors quakes gold pride high schools colleges stanford cal sjsu golf other sports scores / stats ENTERTAINMENT celebrities restaurants movies television music horoscopes comics puzzles and games lottery events arts books LIFE & STYLE food & wine home and garden travel fashion & style pets & animals green living religion OPINION columns editorials letters blogs discussion boards web votes article comments live chats MY CITY san jose / valley los gatos saratoga cupertino sunnyvale campbell central coast peninsula alameda county HELP contact us site map faq widgets start / stop paper advertising buy photos ethics policy past articles PLACE AD place display ad place classified ad SHOPPING newspaper
