Skip to main content

Home/ History Teachers/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by Bette Lou Higgins

Contents contributed and discussions participated by Bette Lou Higgins

David Hilton

How to teach source evaluation? - 70 views

sources evaluation
started by David Hilton on 27 Jul 09 no follow-up yet
  • Bette Lou Higgins
     
    Dear Ben,

    Theatre is always a great way to teach anything -- especially history. Living history programs and projects are everywhere. You can read a short article I wrote on how to create an historical character at: http://www.squidoo.com/characterEVE

    Creating characters and whole scenarios is a great way to get involved in analyzing the source material as well. Of course, it also brings in writing and reading skills. Theatre gives a great perspective to historical events as it lets the student actors actually "walk a mile in my shoes."

    Bette Lou


    Ben Pope wrote:
    > I know I've just caught up with this thread, but I have to say I LOVE the berkeley link, Bette-Lou. I also teach History (Ancient) in Qld, and I know where you're coming from, David. The problem (I think) is made worse in Ancient History, as we have comparatively few sources, and so much conjecture about them. I often feel like I am repeating myself along these lines:
    > So - the author is from the upper class - what is his point of view about the situation?
    > Does this represent a female point of view?
    > etc etc
    >
    > The problem I find is that there often are NO alternative voices, and anything we create is so artificial or one-dimensional - We really don't know how ancient people thought about particular things; so we don't know what they thought was important, or even 'true'.
    >
    > I often use the old Geoffrey Robinson's "Hypothetical" style of roleplay to set up the right kind of mindset for historical analysis - set up your base scenario and let the students play it out, without telling them the real names or events/people. Set constraints/opportunities similar to those enjoyed by historical periods, and see how different/similar your students' solutions are. This rarely needs more than a whiteboard and good stage management...
1 - 1 of 1
Showing 20 items per page