Skip to main content

Home/ Document Wars/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by Alex Brown

Contents contributed and discussions participated by Alex Brown

Alex Brown

Doug Mahugh - 0 views

  • This is the state of formula interoperability among ODF spreadsheets today.
    • Alex Brown
       
      He's right, but I'm not sure this blog posting will attract as much fuss as Rob's red boxes ...
Alex Brown

Gray Matter : Rethinking ODF leadership - 0 views

  • Is it time for Rob to step down as chair? I think so.
    • Alex Brown
       
      That's raising the stakes quite a bit ...
Alex Brown

An Antic Disposition - 2 views

shared by Alex Brown on 04 May 09 - Cached
  • If your business model requires only conformance and not actually achieving interoperability, then I wish you well. But remember that conformance and interoperability are not mutually exclusive options. An application can be conformant to a standard and also be interoperable, if you use the legacy formula namespace and syntax. So the desire to be conformant is not an excuse for not also being interoperable, or at least not a valid excuse.
    • Alex Brown
       
      Also known as "do as I do, not as I say". Of course the real culprit here is ODF itself - not an idea which Rob devotes any time to ...
  • Leadership entails foreseeing and preventing problems, not simply reacting to them.
    • Alex Brown
       
      Yup! So we need a parallel change in the PAS process in preparation for a submission of ODF
Alex Brown

OpenOfficers pitch Oracle on life after Sun * The Register - 0 views

  • John McCreesh, OpenOffice's head of marketing, is veering towards independence, though. He said separately he felt the "right model" is for an independent legal entity to own the trademarks and have joint copyright of the code, with its own finance and governance.
    • Alex Brown
       
      And the key word here is probably "finance".
Alex Brown

IBM Lotus Symphony - Buzz: Document interoperability in Lotus Symphony - 0 views

  • Office 2007 ( OOXML ) import support will be in the next release this quarter.
    • Alex Brown
       
      IBM confirms Symphony will support OOXML (at least to read)
Alex Brown

Groklaw - When Would You Use OOXML and When ODF? -- What is OOXML For? - 0 views

shared by Alex Brown on 28 Apr 09 - Cached
  • If you say Groklaw is an echo chamber, for example, it has insulting connotations
    • Alex Brown
       
      It's also true; but never mind
  • Groklaw deserves respect
    • Alex Brown
       
      The level of self-delusion here is truly scary
  • on a committee set up to help a national body
    • Alex Brown
       
      Oh? I'd be interested to know which NB was nuts enough to appoint Groklaw as an advisor!
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • among others
  • Microsoft (and Alex Brown) are working within JTC1/SC34
    • Alex Brown
       
      Aha, a new line of attack. It is, though, the Countries who want to have the Standard reflect the documents they actually have ...
  •  
    ... and who it's aimed at. It's not as if Groklaw carries any weight (is it?)
Alex Brown

Doug Mahugh : Working with ODF in Word 2007 SP2 - 0 views

  • built-support for ODF 1.1.
    • Alex Brown
       
      So, the cat is now among the pigeons ...
Alex Brown

Groklaw - When Would You Use OOXML and When ODF? -- What is OOXML For? - 0 views

shared by Alex Brown on 28 Apr 09 - Cached
  • The legacy formats are just popped into an OOXML wrapper
    • Alex Brown
       
      Funny how often this old canard is brought out. Do people really belive it?
    • Alex Brown
       
      True, but the stuff inside is XML -- I think there's a widespread view that OOXML is a lot of lightly wrapped BLOBs
Alex Brown

Where is there an end of it? | SC 34 Meetings, Prague, Days 2, 3 & 4 - 0 views

  • I posted this comment, which was deleted
    • Alex Brown
       
      Seems pretty damning ...
Alex Brown

Groklaw - Digging for Truth - 0 views

shared by Alex Brown on 22 Apr 09 - Cached
  • I'm convinced they knew about it already, although it's only a guess
    • Alex Brown
       
      "Reasoning", Groklaw style !
  • the fact that Microsoft would have received a copy
Alex Brown

Moved by Freedom - Powered by Standards » Blog Archive » News of the Weird (A... - 0 views

  • I just don’t get it
    • Alex Brown
       
      Neither do I: but then this is not the first signal of a less than unanimous attitude towards document formats from the Old Firm.
  • The Durban 2 conference in Geneva makes me think of a bizarre mashup of the first Durban conference and what I experienced at the OOXML BRM
    • Alex Brown
       
      Not the first time somebody seems to have got confused between issues of tynanny and totalitarianism, and ... document formats. What price perspective?
    • Alex Brown
       
      He didn't - this is something that Andy Updegrove published at the tim too. What price reality?
  • Alex is right. National transposition is a procedural relic. We should get the specs right out of software vendors and just skip this standardization crap that only justifies to pay useless consultants whose status is construed as some kind of impartial judge. This kind of failed processes have led us to believe that standards and norms could be somehow trusted; as it unfortunately turns out, it stops to be true when strongly applied pressure by one large private monopoly meets the weak morals of the ones in charge of ensuring the process is being duly respected. Thank you Alex, for spelling out the truth. Your lack of impartiality and your strange behaviour during the OOXML standardization process have clarified how poorly qualified you are at patronizing others and lecturing on the ISO and other standards bodies’ processes. I wish you good luck for your next job at Microsoft.
    • Alex Brown
       
      Ah, the sound of a dummy being being spat out ...
Alex Brown

RE: [office] ODF 1.2 drafts/Committee Draft Ballot - 0 views

  • I'm running the version we'll be releasing shortly, which has ODF 1.1 support, and it identifies the problem and offers to repair it
    • Alex Brown
       
      This (slughtly cheeky) posting foreshadows what I suspect is going to be a heated debated about which implementation of ODF is more conformant and whether that matters. Despite the potential for lots of silliness in the sort term, in the long term I think this is going to be healthy for implementations, and for ODF itself (assuming the Oracle takeover of Sun doesn't unduly impact that effort).
‹ Previous 21 - 32 of 32
Showing 20 items per page