Skip to main content

Home/ Groups/ Teaching ICT LIteracy Skills
Katy Field

Industry and Economy - 1 views

  • THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION: CHANGE AND OPPORTUNITY IN ECONOMY AND SOCIETY, c1750-c1830
    • Katy Field
       
      Remember, the debate resolution is: "The technological innovations of the information & communication revolution (1990s - present) have improved the economy more than the technological innovations of the industrial revolution (1800s) did." Stay focused on the actions that must cause an impact (the industrial revolution or the ICT revolution), and the value premise that your evidence must link back to: economic improvement.
  • Although one can find the origins of industrialisation in earlier centuries and although the changes were at a very incomplete stage by the mid nineteenth century, an unprecedented shift was underway which was to change the nature of human society for ever.
    • Katy Field
       
      This quote is not useful for two reasons: first, it only provides a claim (the IR caused longterm changes to human society) , there is no evidence provided to substantiate that claim. Second, the claim itself isn't directly relevant because it simply says that the was a change, it doesn't present any reason to believe that these changes were improvements (which is the value premise of the debate).
  • The industrial revolution certainly saw some dramatic changes in the economy and society of Britain. There was a huge increase in the numbers of people employed in industrial manufacturing, making goods of all kinds, but especially textiles, iron goods, metal wares and pottery, for both overseas and domestic markets.
    • Katy Field
       
      This quote provides EVIDENCE because it states specific facts like the one about increasing number of people employed, and the listing of types of goods being produced. It's RELEVANT to the debate because the facts are about an IMPACT that the industrial revolution had on the economy (# of employed people, types of goods produced), and they LINK back to the value premise (improvement) because you could argue that the economy was improving because the increased number of employed people would have more money in their pockets with which to buy things and continue the cycle of growth. A REBUTTAL might be that the evidence just says that there was a growth in the number of people employed in industrial manufacturing. This does not explicitly say that more people were working overall--they could just be switching the type of job they have, and we don't know that they're getting paid more. An ANSWER to that rebuttal could be that even though the article does not specify the growth in citizens' incomes because of the new type of employment, it is safe to say that people's economic lives were better somehow because they chose to go into these jobs, they were not physically forced, so it must indicate an improvement in their economic lives even though we may not know exactly what kind of improvement that might be.
  • ...3 more annotations...
  • A smaller and smaller proportion of the working population, less than a third by the end of our period, came to live in the countryside and get their living from the land. In the early eighteenth century more than two thirds of the labour force had been in agriculture.
    • Katy Field
       
      This quote could be used in conjunction with another quote that talks about how living in a city is an economic improvement over living in the country to make the argument that more people were living in cities because of the industrial revolution, and that change is an improvement for people, economically. DANGER: if the evidence about the economic value of living in a city is about current day cities, it could open the debater up to a good rebuttal based on the idea that cities in the 1800s aren't necessarily the same as cities in the present.
  • Population growth spurts had happened in earlier centuries but a unique change occurred at this time because such growth did not usher in mass starvation or major increases in disease or mortality (such as had occurred during the Black Death in the 14th century, for example).
    • Katy Field
       
      It looks like a piece of evidence about improvement, but be careful! The improvement discussed (healthier people) doesn't have a clear cause. The quote doesn't say that the industrial revolution caused this health improvement. Not only is this evidence irrelevant because it's not linked back to the industrial revolution, but even if it was, it would take an extra step to argue why health improvements should count as economic improvements. With all of the other good quotes in this source, this one probably isn't worth the effort.
    • Katy Field
       
      A good rebuttal tactic is to critique the reliability of a debater's source. If you cut off the ending of the URL and went to the home page, you can click on the "about" page to learn about the people who wrote the article and sponsor this website. In this case, the source is a group of historians who lobby to protect history. Since they are not a group with an agenda (like a professional group of bankers or unions would be), and they have been educated in history, they can most likely be trusted to report thoughtful and objective material. Thus it's hard to rebut this source.
  •  
    For comprehension activity to prep for economics debate #1
Katy Field

ICT Revolution: The Kids Are Coming! | Kabissa Blog - 0 views

  • Thus the ICT revolution is being transferred into the hands of the young and the results, I am elated to say, is quite impressive and encouraging.
    • Katy Field
       
      This sounds like it has a relevant link and impact, because it says that the ICT revolution is causing "impressive" and "encouraging" changes (both of which sound like an improvements). However, there is no evidence of what it is that is so impressive and encouraging- or that those changes are economic in any way.
  • The Kids love coming as a parent consented “ My boys love coming and learning. They don’t like missing classes.” This means it is interesting.
    • Katy Field
       
      Use ellipses to join this quote with a quote from above or below that states how this ICT club is teaching kids' skills that are economically valuable. Then, you can argue that the ICT revolution made it possible to have these kinds of clubs, and not only are kids immediate qualities of life being improved (because they like the classes), but they are also gaining more marketable skills so they can have improved economic job opportunities in the future.
  • Pastor Bankole Olubamise, an ICT4D Consultant, sent this piece from Abuja.
    • Katy Field
       
      The reliability of this source could be challenged. First, we don't know what Olubamise's profession or educational experiences are--all we know is that he's a pastor, and religious training doesn't make someone an economic expert. Secondly, the home page of the organization that hosts this blog states that it's mission is to use social media to connect people in learning. It's whole existence is based on the ICT revolution, so it may be biased in its perspective that the ICT revolution has brought benefits. Finally, there are no citations in this source, so we don't know where the evidence came from.
  •  
    For comprehension activity to prep for economics debate #1
Nicole Collins

Part III: The Changing Definition of "Research" | Pew Internet & American Life Project - 0 views

    • Nicole Collins
       
      The 'student' definition of research has changed due to technology and busy student life styles
    • Nicole Collins
       
      How do teachers define research?
  • In the case of online databases and printed books, half or more of the teachers who participated in the survey said their students are “not too likely” or “not at all likely” to use these sources.
  • ...1 more annotation...
    • Nicole Collins
       
      If students want easy access to information - why do they overlook databases? Do we not promote these in a way to entice students to bypass google? I have more and more students finding articles via google and then getting stuck because the website will charge a fee to access the article - but we have these same articles available through our databases for free, they just didn't look there.
Nicole Collins

Materials for Faculty: Philosophies and Pedagogies: Teaching Research - 0 views

    • Nicole Collins
       
      Note taking for research
  • Have them form questions about the readings, and then use both Google and scholarly data bases to show them how to find different sources, illustrating the difference between what's found via Google and what's found via Academic Search Premier.
    • Nicole Collins
       
      Comparing Google and Database searches
  • ...4 more annotations...
  • ometimes forget to tell us why the passage they've just quoted is important to their argument.
  • First-year students bring with them some odd ideas about incorporating and citing sources—for instance, if you are paraphrasing rather than quoting an idea you don't need to cite it.
    • Nicole Collins
       
      I get asked this question a lot -  Yes, you still need to cite when paraphrasing
  • Have your students read like scholars, annotating their readings with questions and ideas that they'd like to pursue. Ask them to underline any allusions that the writer makes that they don't fully understand and to do a bit of research.
Nicole Collins

Top 15 Most Popular Social Bookmarking Websites - 1 views

    • Nicole Collins
       
      Really? I haven't heard of half of these.
  •  
    Top Social Bookmarking services
Katy Field

Innovations in ICT teaching: a Guardian roundtable debate | Education | The Guardian - 0 views

  •  
    Another perspective on the contents of ICT Literacy- one that could/should draw in math and computer science folks
Katy Field

Digital Literacy and Citizenship Curriculum for Grades 9-12 | Common Sense Media - 1 views

  •  
    This resource focuses on both the skill set in our ICT Literacy curriculum and the socio-emotional/ethical issues regarding cyber bullying and safety.
Katy Field

Being a Digital Native Isn't Enough | Guest Blog, Scientific American Blog Network - 1 views

  • The split between what Marc Prensky called “digital natives” and “digital immigrants” in his landmark 2001 article has grown wider every year of this century.
    • Katy Field
       
      This is a resource already located within our group of resources.
  •  
    From Matt Scully re: defense of why our kids being immersed in technology is not equivalent to them automatically being proficient in ICT literacy skills.
Nicole Collins

Higher Education: Webinars - 0 views

shared by Nicole Collins on 13 Sep 12 - No Cached
    • Nicole Collins
       
      Hoping to discover what Higher Ed believes is important in terms of ICT skills. Attending the 23rd webinar
Nicole Collins

iSkills and ICT Literacy Assessment: | American Association of School Librarians (AASL) - 0 views

    • Nicole Collins
       
      Do these match with our objectives? Maybe something to consider if ICT skills becomes part of 10-12 grade classes 
  • Inadequate resources (time, space, and instructors) to teach information literacy skills (Callison, 2005)
    • Nicole Collins
       
      These match the pitfalls we are finding
  • Because there is little consistency in what is being taught in K-12 regarding information and communication technology, students are entering colleges and universities with a variety of experiences and knowledge. This complicates ICT curriculum development and begs the questions:
    • Nicole Collins
       
      there is a need for consistency
Nicole Collins

Nicole Collins (1185) - 1 views

  •  
    A personal dashboard to organize all your RSS feeds and blogs you want to follow. Create tabs for different topics or fields followed.
1 - 20 of 63 Next › Last »
Showing 20 items per page