Skip to main content

Home/ SoftwareEngineering/ Group items tagged SOA

Rss Feed Group items tagged

Filter: All | Bookmarks | Topics Simple Middle
kuni katsuya

Dependency injection discourages object-oriented programming? @ Blog of Adam Warski - 0 views

www.warski.org/...es-object-oriented-programming

java javaee6 CDI CdiDependencyInjection OO Object-Oriented procedural DI DependencyInjection

shared by kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12 - No Cached
  • Dependency injection discourages object-oriented programming?
  • if you’re using DI, and you have an X entity, do you have an XService or XManager with lots of method where X is the first argument?
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      evidence of the anti-pattern of procedural design in a java ee6 cdi application
  • previous way is more procedural
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      ie. ProductService.ship(Product,Customer)
  • ...12 more annotations...
  • service/manager is a set of procedures you can run, where the execution takes a product and a customer as arguments
  • better
  • OO approach
  • not saying that achieving the above is not possible with a DI framework
  • only that DI
  • encourages the ProductService approach
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      well, dependency injection, but moreover, the soa approach to service design tends to force otherwise intelligent software engineers into doing procedural design the services just end up being bags of method calls that implement any type of behavior, with the domain objects or entity beans being reduced to mere data structures with little responsibility or behavior beyond persistence. (which, in this anti-pattern, is typically mostly provided by the repository or dao class! ie. domain object crud)
  • it’s just easier
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      ... if you just blindly follow the anti-pattern, of course  ;)
  • many benefits
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      with the procedural approach, you also cannot implement polymorphic behavior, for instance
  • builder
  • fluent interface
  • it’s not for small projects
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      fuckwhat? small or big matters not. if di is applied poorly, regardless of project size, it's an anti-pattern! disregard these comments!
  • problems with DI frameworks:
    • kuni katsuya
      kuni katsuya on 12 Dec 12
       
      not sure i agree with these points, but will refuse in a later sticky note
kuni katsuya

List of E-Books - 0 views

www.sparxsystems.com/...ebook_list.html

enterprisearchitect tricks cookbook

shared by kuni katsuya on 27 Jun 12 - No Cached
  • Modeling Service Oriented-Architectures: An Illustrated Example using Sparx Systems Enterprise Architect
  • Download the E-book in PDF format Download the E-book, Roadmap, Project Template and Rental Car example as a zip file
  • In our third E-book, author Doug Rosenberg (Founder and President of ICONIX Software Engineering, Inc) presents a practical approach to modeling Service-Oriented Architecture solutions from concept to code.
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • Purchase the book at http://leanpub.com/entarch
  • 50 Enterprise Architect Tricks can help you work with elements, diagrams, tagged values, connectors and many other advanced topics.
kuni katsuya

Lean service architectures with Java EE 6 - JavaWorld - 0 views

www.javaworld.com/...-04-lean-soa-with-javaee6.html

javaee6 lean service architecture DAO EntityControlBoundary ECB

shared by kuni katsuya on 30 Jul 12 - No Cached
  • Entity-Control-Boundary (ECB) architectural pattern matches perfectly with our pattern language
  • domain structure is an Entity, the Control is a service, and the Boundary is realized with a facade
  • In simpler cases the facade and service can collapse, and a service would be realized only as a facade's method in that case
kuni katsuya

Lean service architectures with Java EE 6 - JavaWorld - 0 views

www.javaworld.com/...-04-lean-soa-with-javaee6.html

javaee6 lean service architecture DAO

shared by kuni katsuya on 30 Jul 12 - No Cached
  • DAOs aren't dead, but they cannot be considered as a general best practice any more. They should be created in a bottom-up, rather than a top-down, fashion. If you discover data-access code duplication in your service layer, just factor it out to a dedicated DAO and reuse it. Otherwise it is just fine to delegate to an EntityManager from a service. The enforcement of an empty DAO layer is even more harmful, because it requires you to write dumb code for even simple use cases. The more code is produced, the more time you must spend to write tests and to maintain it.
  • With JDK 1.5 and the advent of generics, it is possible to build and deploy a generic, convenient, and typesafe DAO once and reuse it from variety of services
  • kuni katsuya on 30 Jul 12
     
    DAOs aren't dead, but they cannot be considered as a general best practice any more. They should be created in a bottom-up, rather than a top-down, fashion. If you discover data-access code duplication in your service layer, just factor it out to a dedicated DAO and reuse it. Otherwise it is just fine to delegate to an EntityManager from a service. The enforcement of an empty DAO layer is even more harmful, because it requires you to write dumb code for even simple use cases. The more code is produced, the more time you must spend to write tests and to maintain it.
kuni katsuya

Lean service architectures with Java EE 6 - JavaWorld - 0 views

www.javaworld.com/...-04-lean-soa-with-javaee6.html

javaee6 lean service architecture

shared by kuni katsuya on 30 Jul 12 - No Cached
  • key ingredients of a service-oriented component: Facade: Provides simplified, centralized access to the component and decouples the client from the concrete services. It is the network and transaction boundary. Service: The actual implementation of business logic. Domain structure: This is a structure rather than an object. It implements the component's persistence and exposes all of its state to the services, without encapsulation.
  • This convention not only standardizes the structure and improves maintainability, but also allows automatic dependency validation with frameworks like JDepend, Checkstyle,  Dependometer, SonarJ, or XRadar. You can even perform the validation at build time. If you do, the continuous build would break on violation of defined dependencies. The rules are clearly defined with strict layering: a facade may access a service, and the service a domain object, but not vice versa
1 - 8 of 8
Showing 20▼ items per page