On the first question, research shows that teachers are the most important
in-school factor determining students’ academic performance. But they are
not the only in-school factor: class size and the quality of the school
principal, for example, matter a great deal. Most crucially, out-of-school
factors—family characteristics such as income and parents’ education,
neighborhood environment, health care, housing stability, and so on—count for
twice as much as all in-school factors. In 1966, a groundbreaking government
study—the “Coleman Report”—first identified a “one-third in-school factors,
two-thirds family characteristics” ratio to explain variations in student
achievement. Since then researchers have endlessly tried to refine or refute the
findings. Education scholar Richard Rothstein described their results: “No
analyst has been able to attribute less than two-thirds of the variation in
achievement among schools to the family characteristics of their students”
(Class and Schools, 2004). Factors such as neighborhood environment give
still more weight to what goes on outside school.