Skip to main content

Home/ odious debt/ Group items tagged mbeki

Rss Feed Group items tagged

Arabica Robusta

Pambazuka - Moeletsi Mbeki addresses AFRICOM - 0 views

  • On the results of instability, Mbeki said that an important factor that determines whether a country develops or not is, on the one hand, its ability to generate a meaningful economic surplus. On the other hand, it is its ability to direct a large part of that surplus to productive investment rather than merely to private consumption. As a result of Africa's endemic instability, a large part of sub-Saharan Africa's surplus leaves the continent.
    • Arabica Robusta
       
      How does Mbeki's argument here fit into the issue of odious debt? Productive resources are used to sell exotic export crops in order to earn money that is used to pay interest on debts from loans made to dictators that were allies during the Cold War. Meanwhile, food is imported and subsistence land sold to China, Saudi Arabia and others.
  • Assessing Mbeki’s positions is complicated, as one cannot easily discount the accommodation he made to reach out to his audience. After all this is an audience charged with everything from humanitarian relief to covert anti-terror activities, some of whose operations are alleged to violate fundamental international laws.
  • Second, Mbeki posits a developmental model based on comparative advantage, but he does not explain its failure even though it has implemented in many parts of Africa for over 30 years. Yet Mbeki does not hesitate to put the blame ‘in the final analysis’ squarely on African leaders themselves, even though he glosses over the evidence produced by the developmental model he endorses, which north of the Limpopo was foisted on many African countries in the most dastardly circumstances.
  • ...6 more annotations...
  • South Africa endorsed the comparative advantage development model as part of its home-grown structural adjustment programme, GEAR (Growth, Employment and Redistribution strategy). As a consequence of this and other flanking policies, the quality of the composition of its exports has been primitivised and it is more commodity dependent than it was during Apartheid.
  • Third, it is unclear why Mbeki views the US AFRICOM as important. There is already a multilateral body legally charged with maintaining peace and security – the United Nations. The castration of the UN Security Council by the US invention of the concept of pre-emptive war and its invasion of Iraq serves only to weaken the thrust of Mbeki’s case. Not to argue for Africa‘s rights, at the very least, under settled international law is a glaring and pandering omission.
  • Recently the South African Defence Minister Lindiwe Sisulu told Parliament that she wanted the defence force to provide a rite of passage for young people..."l
  • No doubt there are many weary and heavy hearted mothers and fathers across the country that would perceive this as the answer in dealing with their wilfully delinquent and errant adolescents, more out of desperation in the hope that some stern discipline from figures of authority will wise them up to the requirements of life.
  • There are many things that as citizens we do need, and there are many things that the Minister of War and the ANC should be doing for this country, but they have chosen not to – instead they hang yourself on the view that “...We can do that for this country, because that is the one thing we need...” . Sure! You do need to co-opt some of the youth into the army to protect you and your ilk against the rest of the youth and all the workers who take to the streets in righteous indignation to protest against your inept overnment of crony capitalism.
  • America's record is clear - it simply wants control of land (food), water, minerals and energy resources for its own benefit, plus cheap labour. Africom is there to 'command' and prop up servile local elites who will allow American multinationals to take whatever they want. Sadly many of our leaders already eagerly follow the US example of plunder for personal profit and will be happy to get a small personal share of the spoils while their people are impoverished.
1 - 1 of 1
Showing 20 items per page