Justice is an ideal that creates conflict within me when it comes to setting deadlines and accepting late work – a mixed bag of values contradicting each other. Student A works hard, meets deadlines and standards – deserves, wait no, strike that, earns an A. (An arbitrary letter I assign that means something different, and probably does, everywhere else.) Student B, completely capable, doesn’t like to play the game turns in an extraordinary paper, two weeks late, doesn’t follow all of the directions, but clearly gets the concept and exhibits tremendous chops in the skills department. What does this child “deserve”?