Skip to main content

Home/ Law2 Spring 2011/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by Samantha Montalvo

Contents contributed and discussions participated by Samantha Montalvo

Samantha Montalvo

Why did no one notice the boy was missing? - CNN.com - 1 views

  • He was 13 years old -- was no one aware, over the course of two years, that he seemed to have simply vanished?
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand how no one knew he was missing for 2 whole years. I could see a couple weeks maybe even a few months, but 2 years is unbelievable.
  • She said this meant that caseworkers were not looking into the child's situation during the immediate period leading up to his death
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think the caseworkes should be charged with something also, because if they would have done their job this boy might still have been alive.
  • he said he missed his mother and wanted to live with her.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why he got taken from his mother in the first place, this article doesn't say.
  • ...7 more annotations...
  • The boy began to be punished almost immediately
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand if this boy was troubled and deserved stern punishments, or the family is just evil.
  • Christian was made to live inside a used metal dog cage. He allegedly was repeatedly struck and kicked by both his father and stepmother. When Christian tried to escape from the dog cage, his father reportedly secured it with seven locks. The keys were kept near the father's computer, where he was said to enjoy playing video games about racing while his son struggled in the cage.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is so sad, how could a father do these things to his own child. They are inhumane and his father deserves the worse punishment possible!
  • Sometimes Christian's hands were chained to the top of the cage; during one such occasion, according to the affidavit, he was crying, so his stepmother, as additional punishment, spray-painted his chained hands black. His health had started to deteriorate, and he had begun to soil himself, so he was kept naked except for a diaper. The only baths he was permitted were with ice-cold water, which made him scream.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Again, I don't understand how you could put a child through all of this for no apparent reason at all. They all deserve the worse punishments possible! I hope they get the death penalty or life in prison with no food!
  • "He needs to be locked up. He's a dog."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      They are monsters!
  • In April of 2009, according to the affidavit, after Christian was too ill to eat, his father "punched him with full force several times in the front, side and back of his head before throwing him back in the cage."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      If he was this sick, why would his father punch him or even hurt him. If anything he should have helped him, but he's a cold hearted monster.
  • How could a boy live and die, his cries unheard, and have no one be aware of it? How could he be dead for two years and have no one looking for him?
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is one of the saddest things, for two whole years is really unbelieveable.
  • It was the biological mother who, this spring, told police she suspected something bad had happened to Christian.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I'm glad to hear she finally said something. I honestly think she should have said something sooner though because if she hadn't talked to her child in more than 6 months she should have suspected something then.
Samantha Montalvo

Controversial serial killer's paintings go on display in Las Vegas - CNN.com - 0 views

  • A Las Vegas art coordinator's planned charity sale of serial killer John Wayne Gacy's paintings is under fire from the very crime victims group that is supposed to benefit from the proceeds.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why they would even make a charity having anything to do with him.
  • The National Center for Victims of Crime is demanding that its name not be associated with the exhibit, entitled "Multiples: The Artwork of John Wayne Gacy," saying it did not agree to be a beneficiary of the sale.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't see the point in having the charity but not wanting the name being associated with John Wayne Gacy. If its his artwork and benefits are going to families of victims, buyers have the right to know where the artwork came from.
  • After his execution in 1994, his attorney auctioned off his artwork.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      It makes no sense to me why anyone would want to buy the artwork made from a serial killer.
  • ...3 more annotations...
  • Some of it was purchased and destroyed in a bonfire attended by 300 people, including some family members of Gacy's victims.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Im glad that after it was purchased it was destroyed in a bonfire. No one should have that or display it anywhere.
  • Myles said the proceeds would be divided evenly among the charities. If the crime victims group doesn't want the money, Myles said he would find another organization to donate the proceeds.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think they should have just destroyed all the artwork in the first place, because if the victims family members did not agree to have a charity made for them, then they artwork should have been destroyed in the first place.
  • "I think anyone would be pretty creeped out by it,"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I agree with this statement, with the exception of the sick people who believe John Wayne Gacy did no harm.
Samantha Montalvo

Alleged rape, killing of gay rights campaigner sparks call for action - CNN.com - 0 views

  • A 24-year-old who was stabbed to death in South Africa is the victim of "corrective rape," gay rights activists said Thursday, a crime where men attack lesbians in an attempt to reverse their sexual orientation.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why men would actually think raping women would convert their sexuality.
  • She was raped, stabbed with broken glass several times and her face pummelled with rocks, Human Rights Watch said.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why they raped and messed her face up. They believe that raping them will convert their sexuality, so why did they stab and kill her.
  • Earlier this week, the nation's Justice Ministry set up a task force to address hate crimes against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender South Africans.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      They should have been made this organization, so something like this wouldn't have happened.
  • ...6 more annotations...
  • "Her attack is a case of corrective rape," said gay rights activist Lydia Kunu. "Neighbors said they heard her attackers telling her, 'We will take the lesbian out of you. ' They were mocking her and asking her why she acts like a man."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      It's not just a corrective rape, it is also a murder. The definition of rape does not include murder. Just because women act like men does not mean men have the right to do things like this to women.
  • The death has sparked renewed calls for action as rights groups warn of escalated homophobic attacks.
  • Mthathi said it is hard to get an overall number of the people subjected to violence because attacks go unreported over the distrust for the judicial system.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I can definately understand why so many cases go unheard of because no one can be trusted or helped.
  • The use of the term "corrective rape" started three years ago after the rape and murder of Eudy Simelane, a well-known soccer player who lived openly as a lesbian.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      If this kind of situation happened three years ago something should have been done about it then, not waited until it happened again.
  • "It is our responsibility to provide safety, and we take that job seriously,"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      They say this but they haven't done anything to start to end this violence.
  • The new task force is scheduled to start working in July. It will address issues such as whether police and social workers should undergo sensitivity training, and whether rapists who target sexual minorities should get harsher sentences.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      They absolutely should get harsher punishments.
Samantha Montalvo

Body found crucified, wearing crown of thorns - World news - Asia-Pacific - msnbc.com - 0 views

  • The body of a man with his hands and feet nailed to a wooden cross and a crown of thorns on his head has been found in an abandoned stone quarry
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why people would want to "reenact" this horrible situation. If they truely understood what Jesus went through, why put another human being through this.
  • A man wearing only underwear, with a wound on the side of his torso and nylon strings tied around his neck, arms and stomach, was found crucified Sunday
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is really sad that a man really had to suffer all of this, whoever did it probably wanted to send a message, but this a horible way to send it.
  • Police are waiting for a forensic report to determine the exact time and cause of the man's death and whether it was a homicide or suicide.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't see how they are even considering suicide? How can he nail himself to a cross and set everything up.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • Police had not ruled out murder or whether other people had helped Kim to kill himself, AFP said.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Even if he told somebody or people to help him kill himself I don't understant why they would listen to him and help because it is just morally wrong and they are putting themselves in the sitaution to be charged with assisted suicide.
Samantha Montalvo

Toddler shoots mom dead, boy's father tells Florida police - CNN.com - 0 views

  • The father, who called 911, told police he was trying to take the firearm away from the child when it discharged.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why the gun wasn't on some type of safety mode.
  • What we do know is that last Wednesday, shortly after 7 o'clock, we received a 911 call from a gentleman stating that his 2-1/2-year-old son accidentally shot his mother
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      It is really hard to believe that a two and a half year old is capable of shooting and killing his mother with a gun, or any other object.
  • "My son picked it up and I tried to grab it," the man said about the gun. "Oh God, I can't believe this."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This situation must be really hard for the father, because there is that chance that investigators will nor believe him that his son shot her, they might try to say that he shot her and is trying to blame it on his son.
Samantha Montalvo

Florida divorce proceeding turns violent -- in judge's chambers - CNN.com - 0 views

  • nal hearing in her divorce case.
  • Catherine Scott-Go
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      That's a really foolish decision he made, now he is going to get divorced and charged for assault.
  • "I just can't believe that it happened -- there are just no words for it," Scott-Gonzalez said Tuesday, as she continued to recover from a broken nose and a fractured jaw
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This woman was already going through stress with the divorce and now she has to deal with her injuries. He should pay for pain and suffering.
  • ...4 more annotations...
  • "In addition to the violence, the fact is that it happened in a court proceeding."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is true, the fact that it even happened and that is happened during court.
  • "He goes, 'I'm not going to pay child support,' and Judge Rothschild says, 'You know all parents have to pay child support, we all have to support our children,' and he (Gonzalez) stalked out of the room," said Dunleavy. "He went calmly," remembered Judge Rothschild, "not happily, but calmly walked out of chambers, took one step out of the door, then in a blink of an eye -- I mean literally one step -- he came back in." Upon returning, Gonzalez suddenly started punching his estranged wife, according to those in the chambers.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is so sad that he did this to the mother of his child regardless of their dispute. If his child finds out what he did his child could lose all his repsect for his father.
  • A bailiff was not in the room at the time. The judge said if he had had any indication that Gonzalez was violent, he would have had security in his chambers.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      No matter what, there should always be security in the courtroom regardless of whether the judge thinks people are violent or not.
  • Violence is not OK any where but it is certainly not OK in the court of law in the United States of America."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think he should have thought about this fact before hand and maybe this wouldn't have happened.
Samantha Montalvo

Police: Skull, remains found on Long Island are human - CNN.com - 0 views

  • Remains found Monday on Long Island, New York, have been identified as being human, police said Tuesday.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I wonder how old the remains are.
  • Those were located about four hours before the skull by a New York state police officer and his cadaver dog, about a mile and a half away.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is really interesting that dogs can smell dead bodies.
  • Investigators are working on the presumption that a single person is responsible for the deaths. The four victims who have been identified thus far all advertised prostitution services on websites such as Craigslist, authorities have said.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      People that can actually keep killing with no remorse are sick and need help.
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • Gilbert's sisters said Shannan was an escort who was visiting a client. They said she ran from the man's house and called 911, claiming that someone was trying to hurt her.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      If this woman would not have gotten away she would have been the tenth victim and body found. Luckily she did get away.
  • Sherre Gilbert said even if her sister is never found, the search has led to one positive outcome: the discovery of the other women's bodies.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This statement is very true.
Samantha Montalvo

Duke lacrosse accuser arrested in boyfriend's stabbing - CNN.com - 0 views

  • The woman who accused three Duke University lacrosse players of rape five years ago was arrested Sunday, suspected of stabbing her boyfriend, police said.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think this woman has a psychological problems, and an issue towards men.
  • found a 46-year-old man who had been stabbed in the torso, police said. He was taken to Duke University Hospital for treatment of serious injuries.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand why she would stab her boyfriend, it doesn't say a reason to why.
  • Officers said the stabbing occurred during an argument at the couple's shared apartment.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      An argument is no reason to stab and try to kill someone.
Samantha Montalvo

Texas day care owner charged with murder in fire - CNN.com - 0 views

  • Jessica Tata had previously been charged with six counts of reckless injury to a child and several charges of manslaughter. She will be in court to face the new charges on Friday.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't understand if she had been previously charged with assault before than why was she trusted around children again
  • Tata, who has dual citizenship in the United States and Nigeria, fled to the African nation shortly after the fatal fire at her Houston home in February.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is obviously a sign that she was guilty and wanted to flee the country.
  • Investigators allege that Tata, 22, left seven children alone at her Houston day care center with the stove on while she went to a store. Four children died, and three others were injured in the fire.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is so horrible! I can't believe she actually would leave them completely alone AND leave the oven on.
Samantha Montalvo

California mother arrested for encouraging son to fight - CNN.com - 0 views

  • At one point in the video, circulated on the internet, the woman offers pointers to her son on how to win the fight. She also assures the combatants they have permission to fight in her yard and that she will not call the police.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This shows a lot of lack or parenting and good judgement. I wonder how the mother would feel if her child got in to a fight somewhere else without her being there and the other child's mother was helping their child.
  • "Jennifer can be heard and seen in the video yelling and encouraging her son to batter the other juvenile. Jennifer is heard yelling a barrage of profanities and enticing the fight,"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      If she doesn't already feel embarrassed, she should.
  • Police also credited a man who witnessed the fight and can be seen on the video stopping it.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      It's good somebody finally stopped the fight, because obviously this mother would never have stopped it.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • "Lady, you're letting them fight like this? What kind of example are you, lady?" the man asks. "I don't care," the woman replies.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is a real shame that this mother feels like this, her son or the other child could have seriously got injured and she would have been held responsible for any injuries for letting it go on instead of stopping it.
Samantha Montalvo

Alleged gang rape of girl, 11, ignites firestorm in Texas community - CNN.com - 0 views

  • The alleged gang rape of an 11-year-old girl has torn apart a Texas community, with some focusing on the girl and her parents as much as, if not more than, the 18 people accused of sexually assaulting her.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is so disgusting and horrible that these people could do this to an 11 year old little girl.
  • This month, police said 13 adults and five juveniles have been arrested related to their investigation of an alleged rape late last year in Cleveland
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This eitghteen or more people deserve a life sentence in prison with no chance or parol.
  • Darrell Broussard, Cleveland's assistant police chief, said that the 18 individuals charged thus far are between 14 and 27 years old.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Thats sad that the youngest was fourteen years old and just wasted most of his life now because he'll be facing many years in prison because of his careless actions.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • Among other issues, he said that the girl didn't do enough to stop the alleged assailants.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      How much can eleven year old do to defend herself against 18 adults and juveniles?
Samantha Montalvo

7 children die in Pennsylvania house fire - CNN.com - 0 views

  • The children -- ages 7 months to 11 years
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      They were so young and helpless.
  • "While mom's milking cows, her 3-year-old daughter comes running into the barn and the 3-year-old tells the mother that there's smoke inside the house," Pinkerton said. "Mom leaves the barn, comes running out, sees that the house appears to be on fire."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      That's crazy how a 3 year old was smart enough to know there was something wrong and went and told her mother, unfortuneately the child didn't inform the others children in the house first.
  • The children -- six girls and a boy -- were found dead inside the house
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      It's so unfortuante that so many children died, but luckily one survived.
Samantha Montalvo

Sentencing due in hate crime killing of immigrant - CNN.com - 0 views

  • Two men convicted of a hate crime in the beating death of an undocumented Mexican immigrant are scheduled to be sentenced Wednesday in a Pennsylvania federal court.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I didn't know people still committed hate crimes just because of your race. I think it's so sad that they resulted in killing him instead of turning him in to immagration offices.
  • The two had previously been acquitted of murder charges in state court and convicted of simple assault.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is not simple assault at all. They should be charged with first degree murder because they knew exactly what they're doing.
  • witnesses testified that racist language was used before and during the attack and that Ramirez was kicked in the head repeatedly after he fell down. The defendants, they said, didn't want immigrants in their neighborhood and repeatedly ordered Ramirez to leave.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is NO excuse at all to do something like this. Even if they were upset that an immigrant was in their neighborhood, like I said before they should have just called the authorities!
Samantha Montalvo

Man opens fire on girlfriend along Vegas freeway ยป Kitsap Sun - 0 views

  • A fight in a moving vehicle ended in gunfire after a man shot his female acquaintance
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Thats really crazy that a person can get so angry over an argument and then shoot his girlfriend.
  • Police say the man punched one of his friends and then assaulted the woman.
  • The woman and the two friends ran from the car, but the gunman followed, shooting the woman as motorists zoomed past
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      The fact that they tried to run from him and he chased after them with a shotgun and proceeded to shoot her makes it all worse.
Samantha Montalvo

New Jersey Man Convicted of Manslaughter in British Reality TV Star's Death - FoxNews.com - 0 views

  • A New Jersey man who admitted killing one of Britain's most eligible bachelors was convicted Wednesday of reckless manslaughter and weapons offenses stemming from the August 2007 slaying.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think the only reason why he admitted it was because he had a guilty conscience after so many years. Even though he should have turned himself in right away, its good that he finally turned himself in.
  • believing the man who was a reality show competitor in the U.K. was part of a group out to hurt or kill him.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Even though he thought this man was out to get him, this is still no reason to killl him, especially because he didn't have any evidence or poof.
  • Davies faces up to 10 years in prison.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I thought if someone killed another person they got life in prison?
Samantha Montalvo

Party ejection led to Ohio frat house shooting, police say - CNN.com - 0 views

  • killing one and wounding 11, were apparently angry because they were being thrown out of a party there, police said Monday.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Being thrown out of a party is no reason to start shooting.
  • Police identified the suspects in the Sunday shooting as Columbus E. Jones, 22, and Braylon L. Rogers, 19, both Youngstown residents.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Wow, they are so young.
  • Jamail Johnson, 25, of Girard, Ohio, died in the shooting. He was shot once in the back of the head and several times in the lower body,
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Wow that's so brutal and sad!
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • "I'm hurting for him right now," Baker said. "I'm just surprised he had to be the one in the crossfire."
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Aww that's so sad that this happened to someone so innocent.
Samantha Montalvo

Search warrant details scene where bodies of Florida teens found - CNN.com - 0 views

  • Schenecker, 50, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the January 28 deaths of her 13-year-old son, Beau Powers Schenecker, and her 16-year-old daughter, Calyx Powers Schenecker.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is really sad that a mother could really kill her children. I don't understand any reason in the world to do something so horrible like this.
  • She was denied bond
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Good!
  • Police found Calyx's body in an upstairs bedroom. She had been shot twice in the head, police said. Beau's body was later found in the front seat of an SUV inside the home's garage, police said. They said he was shot while he was being driven to soccer practice.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is horrible! I can't believe she could really shoot her children!
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • Police later found writings in the house, thought to be from Schenecker, in which she spelled out her intentions in detail
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      The fact that she planned this makes it all so much worse! This woman should be given the death penalty.
  • A responding officer, Julie Becker, wrote that she didn't see any "visible injuries" on Calyx, nor did the girl complain of any. "She seemed cautious of what was saying, and at times began to cry,"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I think she was abused but her mother threatened to beat her more or even kill her if she said anything to the police.
Samantha Montalvo

Ex-convict arraigned in 5 Detroit rapes this month | Top AP Stories | Chron.com - Houst... - 0 views

  • "You take a boy, you find him guilty and stick him in the belly of the beast, you create a monster,"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't agree with this statement because it's not like he was a completely innocent man that was thrown in jail for no reason. It seems like e had trouble very early on in his life.
  • "It looks like it's going to be an uphill battle," Galen said of the case.
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      I don't see how this case is going to be an uphill battle because it seems like it's all self-explanatory. He's guitly of all the charges made against him. He should just be sent to jail.
  • Indeed, some men using bullhorns walked and declared, ""There's a rapist on the loose and he's in your neighborhood!"
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      Not saying these women are right for this but at least they're letting others in the neighborhood know what is going on. Even tho they should have handled it a lot better than this.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • He began his sentence as a teenager in juvenile facilities but was transferred to a regular prison at age 18,
    • Samantha Montalvo
       
      This is why I said he probably had trouble very early on in life and right here proves it because he started off in a juvenile center than straight to a regular prison.
1 - 18 of 18
Showing 20 items per page