FIGURE 1. Craft Techniques and Related Questions for Close Reading
Craft Technique
Possible Questions
Imagery, including comparisons:
Similes
Metaphors
Personification
Figurative language
Symbols
What is being compared?
Why is the comparison effective? (typically because of the clear, strong, or unusual connection between the two)
What symbols are present? Why did the author choose these symbols?
Word choice
What word(s) stand out? Why? (typically vivid words, unusual choices, or a contrast to what a reader expects)
How do particular words get us to look at characters or events in a particular way? Do they evoke an emotion?
Did the author use nonstandard English or words in another language? Why? What is the effect?
Are there any words that could have more than one meaning? Why might the author have played with language in this way?
Tone and voice
What one word describes the tone?
Is the voice formal or informal? If it seems informal, how did the author make it that way? If it's formal, what makes it formal?
Does the voice seem appropriate for the content?
Sentence structure
Short sentence
Long sentences
Sentence fragments
Sentences in which word order is important
Questions
What stands out about the way this sentence is written?
Why did the author choose a short sentence here? (for example, so it stands out from sentences around it, for emphasis)
Why did the author make this sentence really long? (for example, to convey the "on and on" sense of the experience.)
Why did the author write a fragment here? (for example, for emphasis or to show a character's thoughts)
Based on the order of the words in this sentence, which word do you think is the most important? Why? What was the author trying to show by placing a particular word in a certain place?
Getting students to ask themselves the four general questions and the more specific questions about