Skip to main content

Home/ gcanth103dspring2013/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by andrew carlino

Contents contributed and discussions participated by andrew carlino

J Scott Hill

What are the major accusations or questions of debate concerning "Darkness in El Dorado?" - 70 views

questions
started by J Scott Hill on 31 Jan 13 no follow-up yet
  • andrew carlino
     
    The major issue to me in this article was the fact that many of Neel and Chagnon's findings were very loosely based on fact when they were further explored. Other anthropologists had studied many of the same tribes that they had and came up with completely different interpretations of the Yanomami's culture and way of life. Not only were they based mostly on fiction, but there are many reasons to believe that Chagnon and Neel were bribing the Yanomami with machetes and other items in order to get them to act in a desired way. Ultimately, while both of these anthropologists did extensive work with the Yanomami, one must always consider their bias and motives for writing before completely accepting their writings as facts.
1 - 1 of 1
Showing 20 items per page