Skip to main content

Home/ Emerson ITG - What we're reading/ Group items tagged critical

Rss Feed Group items tagged

jenn stevens

Why Students Can't Write - And Why Tech Is Part of the Problem - EdSurge News - 0 views

  •  
    Clickbait title but interesting criticism of Turnitin, LMS, and conditions necessary for creativity
jenn stevens

The average AI criticism has gotten lazy, and that's dangerous - Redeem Tomorrow - 0 views

  •  
    Dude has absolutely no interest in or sympathy for higher ed, but the rest of the essay is super interesting.
jenn stevens

5 Things You Need to Know Before You Buy Edtech #OTESSA23 - 0 views

  •  
    Thought this was interesting, particularly slides 11 and 12, that complicate my notion that pedagogy should drive technology. Not sure what I think of the environmental considerations, need to look into that more.
jenn stevens

Universal Design for Learning and Digital Accessibility: Compatible Partners or a Confl... - 0 views

  • For now, we recommend waiting out the waves of accessibility standards implementation. Discuss implementation options with university stakeholders, but resist locking onto an approach until your institution's leadership has solidified a definite plan and enacted accountability measures. Throughout the often lengthy process of determining an accessibility action plan, your university may consider everything from requiring accurate captions for every video within the next year to encouraging best practices and collecting data on gradual standard adoption. Although it is important to hold discussions, we recommend waiting as long as necessary before locking into a specific plan; doing so avoids having to change training material and messages to faculty, such as whether accessibility implementation is "required" or "recommended."
  • Adopt a social justice model uniting UDL and accessibility with other student success initiatives. Create a culture that supports students with diverse learning and life needs. A social justice model supports equal opportunity for all students, especially historically disadvantaged groups. Although institutions must comply with ADA and Section 508, accessibility can go beyond the law to embrace critical values and beliefs about diversity and social justice.
  • ongoing progress that demonstrates a commitment to continual improvement.
  • ...3 more annotations...
  • institutions have been required to dedicate staff and services to completely overhaul their websites and instructional content, most have come to an agreement with OCR to comply with Section 508.
  • Lecture-capture recordings
  • Another key UDL practice is "representing" instructional content
  •  
    Great overview of how accessibility connects to UDL and why accessibility standards without resources/instruction can sometimes be a barrier to UDL.
jenn stevens

AI Is Unavoidable, Not Inevitable - by Marc Watkins - 0 views

  • I think generative AI is unavoidable, not inevitable
  • engaging AI doesn’t mean adopting it
  • Every one of us is already so entwined with dozens of mega-corporations that we support daily through use with all the things that we find necessary to function in our very busy, very online lives, that resisting even one of those is a daunting task. The amount of energy, time, focus, and potential loss of access means we’re all unlikely to resist or look for legitimate alternatives to any of the tools or services I’ve mentioned above.
  • ...9 more annotations...
  • How do we move from recognizing our technological dependence to making meaningful choices about new technologies like AI? The answer isn't found in moral outrage alone.
  • Our inability to disconnect from technology and make critical, informed decisions is the problem I’d like us to explore, not simply generative AI.
  • We should all advise people to be cautious and skeptical about generative technology because we know very little about how it will impact our lives, not base our objections on value-based judgments about the ethics of using one form of technology v. another in a vast sea of already deeply unethical innovations we all consume daily.
  • Namely generating text doesn’t use much energy compared to streaming an episode of Netflix.
  • Data centers as a whole only use up around 1% to 2% of total energy demand. Most of that isn’t from AI. It comes from a mix of social media, data processing, and cryptocurrency.
  • The screen you are reading this on, like the smartphone in your pocket, wasn’t ethically sourced or sustainably made. The labor used to mine those resources and assemble the final product was invisible and exploitative—like so much of the economic forces that fuel our reality.
  • Our students deserve spaces where such inquiry is welcome and not boiler plated away behind pro-AI adoption initiatives or anti-AI policies within our institutions or our courses.
  • Most importantly, we all deserve some grace here. Dealing with generative AI in education isn’t something any of us asked for. It isn’t normal.
  • Engaging AI in education requires far more resources and time than anyone wants to admit. It also calls for a level of nuance we’re not going to find on our social media feeds. I don’t know enough about generative tools and you likely don’t either to make the important decisions necessary to chart the best path forward for myself or my students with the AI we have today, let alone the AI that is on the near horizon.
1 - 13 of 13
Showing 20 items per page