Skip to main content

Home/ CUPE Health Care/ Group items tagged private clinic

Rss Feed Group items tagged

Govind Rao

For-Profit Medicare Home Health Agencies' Costs Appear Higher And Quality Appears Lower... - 0 views

  • For-profit, or proprietary, home health agencies were banned from Medicare until 1980 but now account for a majority of the agencies that provide such services. Medicare home health costs have grown rapidly since the implementation of a risk-based prospective payment system in 2000. We analyzed recent national cost and case-mix-adjusted quality outcomes to assess the performance of for-profit and nonprofit home health agencies. For-profit agencies scored slightly but significantly worse on overall quality indicators compared to nonprofits (77.18 percent and 78.71 percent, respectively). Notably, for-profit agencies scored lower than nonprofits on the clinically important outcome “avoidance of hospitalization” (71.64 percent versus 73.53 percent). Scores on quality measures were lowest in the South, where for-profits predominate. Compared to nonprofits, proprietary agencies also had higher costs per patient ($4,827 versus $4,075), were more profitable, and had higher administrative costs. Our findings raise concerns about whether for-profit agencies should continue to be eligible for Medicare payments and about the efficiency of Medicare’s market-oriented, risk-based home care payment system.
Govind Rao

Catching Up on the False Claims Act - Infomart - 0 views

  • Corruption, Crime & Compliance Tue Jan 27 2015,
  • From a corporate risk perspective, if your company is in the financial industry, healthcare, or defense industry, your greatest legal and compliance risk has to be the False Claims Act. I know that is heresy to all the legal "marketing/fear" publications focused on the FCPA, but for many companies, the FCA is a greater risk. Add to the FCA mix a well-established whistleblower scheme - qui tam relators - and there is your recipe for disaster. In the healthcare industry, the government is focused on providers, particularly hospitals. The government's motivation is easy to discern - they want to keep medical costs down and hospitals are the biggest factor in this payment mix. Healthcare clinics, home health services and skilled nursing facilities are other providers on the government hit list.
  • Community Health Systems, the largest operator of acute care hospitals, paid $98 million to settle seven lawsuits brought by qui tam relators, and entered into a five-year Corporate Integrity Agreement with HHS. Community Health Systems engaged in a deliberate strategy to increase inpatient admissions of patients who entered emergency departments. The relators in these cases included nurses, billing personnel, and emergency room physicians. Another significant hospital case was brought against Halifax Hospital Medical Center, which is based in Florida, that agreed to pay $85 million to resolve Stark law violations. In the home healthcare services area, Amedisys, one of the largest home healthcare providers agreed to pay $150 million to resolve a number of qui tam relator lawsuits, along with a five-year CIA with HHS. Amedisys billed Medicare for nursing and therapy services that were medically unnecessary or were for services to patients who were not limited to home residence.
Govind Rao

Ambassadors engaged in employee satisfaction efforts - Infomart - 0 views

  • National Post Mon Feb 2 2015
  • For the past eight years, Covenant Health has operated a unique employee engagement program utilizing hundreds of specially trained staff dubbed as engagement ambassadors to improve the lives of fellow employees. Specially trained in the issues surrounding engagement, the Edmonton-based health-care provider currently has 296 ambassadors charged with sharing knowledge of engagement best practices and promoting a positive work environment. "The senior team recognized the importance of focussing on employee engagement and created a program to support it," says Karen Zarsky, the health-care provider's director of organizational effectiveness, learning and development.
  • The ambassadors, spread out across the province of Alberta, have allowed the organization to provide training to leaders to support and strengthen employee engagement as well as to identify and celebrate "everyday heroes" who have done something large or small for patients or fellow employees. "To me, the biggest win [from the ambassador program] is celebrating our everyday heroes," says Zarsky. Engagement ambassadors also organize celebratory events for their teams, advocate for resources for their team or department and create new employee recognition programs. "I think that people are more open to sharing their ideas for improvement," says Sherry Lucas, a clinical safety co-ordinator with Covenant Health's Bonnyville Health Centre, with 335 employees located two hours north of Edmonton.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • She has been an ambassador for the past two years, adding she hopes to stay in the role of engagement cheerleader for "as long as I'm here, probably." While somewhat geographically isolated, she connects with other ambassadors either online or through conference calls to share ideas and successes. "We discuss how to keep people's hearts at work and keep them happy here - and engaged."
Govind Rao

New assistance programs for paramedics underway - Infomart - 0 views

  • The Daily Gleaner (Fredericton) Wed Mar 11 2015
  • After a national survey of paramedics released last month documented high stress levels among New Brunswick's emergency medical professionals, officials with Ambulance New Brunswick announced they'd be bringing forward new programming to assist employees. So far there's no word on when those new programs will be available, though it looks like work is underway to prepare them for an upcoming roll-out. In October 2014, the Paramedic Association of Canada invited paramedics from coast to coast to fill out a confidential online survey, which asked questions to assess whether or not they've struggled with mental health problems.
  • Designed by a clinical psychologist who works with the Toronto Paramedic Services, the poll was completed by more than 6,000 paramedics. Nearly 350 of the roughly 1,100 paramedics working in New Brunswick shared their experiences for the survey. Their responses provided some troubling statistics about the pressures these skilled individuals face on the job and in their personal lives. About 30 per cent of the responding paramedics reported they'd contemplated suicide. When asked if they knew any co-workers who had thought about taking their own lives, that number more than doubled to 70 per cent. About 79 per cent said they've worried about a colleague's well-being.
  • ...5 more annotations...
  • Ambulance NB has a number of resources already in place to support its paramedics, flight nurses and medical dispatchers. There's a critical incident stress-management program, which is supported by the Department of Health and the College of Psychologists of New Brunswick. It offers peer-to-peer support for paramedics who've responded to difficult calls. The provincial ambulance service also has a free, confidential employee and family assistance program. It's available around the clock and offers employees one-on-one counselling to help them cope with stresses from work or home. Tracy Bell, a spokeswoman for Ambulance NB, told The Daily Gleaner in February that the organization was taking steps to expand its offerings to paramedics.
  • "We recognize that we need to do more to support our front-line employees and are taking the necessary steps to get there," she said. "In addition to existing resources, Ambulance NB will be introducing an expanded employee support program in the coming weeks. We are also looking seriously at what options are available in terms of facilitating direct access to a mental health professional or network of professionals for our employees. We hope to be able to be able to share news of these new initiatives with staff very soon." When the newspaper asked for an update this week, Bell said Ambulance NB is still working on this project. "Ambulance NB looks forward to being able to share news of new mental health supports with our employees soon," she said. "Our priority is to share information first with our paramedics, dispatchers and flight nurses." Judy Astle, president of paramedics union CUPE Local 4848, said she's still waiting for some more information. "They supposedly have what they're calling an enhanced employee assistance program. But we have not seen the details as a union yet," she said.
  • "We have a labour management meeting coming up next week. They may present it there. That's what we're hoping." Astle said enhancing the mental health resources for paramedics should help many professionals deal with the difficulties they experience in the line of duty. "Anything that's going to try to prevent high levels of stress in our job is valuable. It's hard to do. But the support is needed out there," she said. "It's a very trying job, to say the least. What affects me may not affect someone else. But what could affect them may not affect someone else. It's often a build up of things." MLA Ross Wetmore, the Progressive Conservative member who represents the Gagetown-Petitcodiac region, recently introduced a private member's bill in the New Brunswick legislature designed to eliminate the need for first responders to prove their post-traumatic stress disorder was caused while on the job. If it passes, that could eliminate the mountains of red tape that many first responders now face as they seek benefits while on leave for treatment.
  • Specifically, Bill 15 would amend the Workers' Compensation Act to presume post-traumatic stress disorder in first responders has been caused by "a traumatic event or a series of traumatic events to which the worker was exposed" while at work. That would apply to both current and former firefighters, paramedics, police officers and sheriffs who have been diagnosed as having PTSD by a physician or psychologist. A second part of the bill would require workers' compensation to offer, "treatment by culturally competent clinicians who are familiar with the research concerning treatment of first responders for post-traumatic stress disorder." Astle said she supports the bill, and says it could really help first responders as they struggle to get the help they need. "That was fantastic. That's a step in the right direction," she said. "People are talking about it more, are relating to it more. In our job, we're supposed to be the 'tough guy.' We have to share with our co-workers some of the things that are bothering us. Most of us do that. We talk it out." Chris Hood, executive director of the Paramedics Association of New Brunswick, said he's going to be meeting with government soon to ask for their support of this legislation, though he currently doesn't know how they feel about such a program. "We don't know whether or not government is going to support it," he said.
  • Hood said his organization wants to join the effort to make life easier for paramedics. So it's announced a few goals for the future. "We're working towards increased screening and education prior to entering the profession, improved training during the (early stages of your career), high-quality mental health support through a team of dedicated practitioners during your employment, and then the presumptive diagnosis legislation (introduced by Wetmore)," he said.
Govind Rao

Alberta to add beds, improve emergency care wards to ease bottlenecks; Alberta to add c... - 0 views

  • Canadian Press Wed Mar 11 2015
  • EDMONTON - Alberta paramedics will be allowed to do more for patients to help relieve a bottleneck leading to long waits in emergency care. It's one of three initiatives announced Wednesday by Health Minister Stephen Mandel. He says as of this summer, paramedics will provide more front-line care in clinics and regional hospitals by handling duties such as portable lab analysis. The province also plans to open 311 new restorative care beds to help seniors transition from hospitals back to their homes
  • There is also to be $50 million to increase capacity and improve care in emergency rooms in Edmonton and Calgary over the next two years. Mandel says the government is working to protect front-line care, even though it is planning five per cent spending cuts across the board in the next budget. Sandra Azocar, executive director of Friends of Medicare, said the announcement included no details on how the funding would be allocated between the five facilities or what specific renovations or expansions would take place, nor did it say if any additional staff would be hired with the expansions.
  • ...4 more annotations...
  • "It is also not clear why the brand new South Health Campus in Calgary requires renovation or expansion, or how the crumbling Misericordia Hospital will survive when it alone needs over $100 million in upgrades within the next few years," she said in a news release. Azocar said the PC government opened medical transition beds in hospitals in 2010 to deal with the same issues of overcrowded ERs, but closed them in 2013. "They have already closed 36 surgical beds this year at the Peter Lougheed Hospital, replacing them with the rapid transit beds announced last month.
  • "Today's beds appear to be very similar to the medical transition beds and the rapid transit beds but with a new name: restorative beds," she said. The group that represents about 25,000 health-care professionals in Alberta, including EMS workers, called Mandel's announcement "more smoke and mirrors than real facts."
  • "I know Premier Jim Prentice doesn't like to talk about mirrors nowadays, but this announcement of restorative beds and changes to the role paramedics seems to promise much, but deliver little," says Elisabeth Ballermann, president of the Health Sciences Association of Alberta. She added that the announcement leaves more questions than answers. Ballermann said one question is whether the 311 restorative beds are in addition to the 464 new continuing-care spaces announced in October 2014.
  • She also wondered if the beds will be in public or private, for-profit facilities and if the funding will come from the Alberta Supportive Living Initiative new money or part of the $60 million announced in October.
Govind Rao

February newsletter: Important updates on the Cambie Trial - 0 views

  • A message from Dr. Monika Dutt At the end of August, Dr. Brian Day's legal team requested a delay of trial. Along with our allies, we at CDM were hopeful that the delay would lead to a resolution that defended Medicare against for-profit interests.  
  • But last week we learned that a resolution has not been reached, and the trial that threatens to destroy Canadian Medicare will begin this spring. On March 2, Day will re-launch his court challenge, alleging that the Canada Health Act is a violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Govind Rao

Women reluctant to co-operate with anti-abuse body; Victims' lack of confidence in syst... - 0 views

  • Toronto Star Sat Apr 11 2015
  • In late February, a first consultation with task force co-chairs Marilou McPhedran and Sheila Macdonald heard from experts in the field. A little more than a month later, three victims shared their testimonies publicly at a second session. Public consultations are not the only way for victims to tell their stories. In an email to the Star Thursday, David Jensen, a spokesman for Ontario's Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, said three more victims have come forward to the task force during two private consultations. They can also request to tell their stories by telephone conversations, letters, emails or other written communication. When asked if she would consider telling her story at the next consultation on Monday, Brooks said she believes her story would "absolutely" be ignored. "If I thought there was any input that I could give that would actually make a difference, I would be front of the line. But I don't think there's anything that will change."
  • The ministry is using print advertising and social media to raise awareness about the consultations, said Jensen. They have also contacted survivor organizations, provided McPhedran and Macdonald with a list of contacts, and engaged both the Metropolitan Action Committee on Violence Against Women and Children and the Ontario Coalition of Rape Crisis Centres to help get the word out, he said. Nicole Pietsch, co-ordinator of the rape crisis centres coalition, said she was the one who reached out to the Ministry of Health after learning about the public consultations through a fellow community group. "You've got to think - we have 26 sexual assault centres across the province. That's all kinds of sexual violence, but I would say most centres are hearing from survivors of patient sexual abuse. We see those cases, not loads and loads, but every year we do see those cases," she said. The information about the session is reaching the public only now, Pietsch said. Consultations with the task are supposed to last only through April. Amanda Dale, executive director with woman's legal centre the Barbra Schlifer Clinic, said she only vaguely remembers getting a letter from the ministry about the consultation.
Govind Rao

Ambulance fees an obstacle to 19% of Canadians; Compassionate approach that balances co... - 0 views

  • Hamilton Spectator Fri Apr 10 2015
  • Imagine you're a physician seeing a six-month-old child in clinic. She has a fever and cough, she's working hard to breathe and her oxygen levels are falling. You know she needs assessment in the emergency room and requires transportation in an ambulance in case her condition worsens en route. Her family understands the urgency of the situation, but asks, "Could we take her there in our car?" Experiencing a medical emergency is an incredibly stressful experience for patients and their families. This stress should not be compounded by worries about getting an ambulance bill they can't afford. As physicians, we know the importance of the first few minutes of an emergency situation, and the crucial role of emergency medical services (EMS) in saving lives. And yet ambulance fees remain a significant barrier to people receiving necessary care across Canada. One young mother recently spoke to the Saskatchewan press about receiving a bill of $7,000 after several ambulance trips were required for her severely ill daughter. Connie Newman of the Manitoba Association of Seniors Centres recently described to reporters the plight of an elderly woman who walked to hospital in -40 C weather because she could not afford an ambulance. How often are people forced to choose the unsafe option of driving themselves or their loved ones to hospital simply because they cannot afford to pay?
  • A recent CBC "Marketplace" survey revealed 19 per cent of Canadians did not call an ambulance due to cost. Clearly, this is an issue our provincial and territorial health ministers need to address.
  • ...2 more annotations...
  • Ryan Meili is an expert adviser with EvidenceNetwork.ca, a family physician in Saskatoon and founder of Upstream: Institute for A Healthy Society. @ryanmeili
  • Carolyn Nowry is a family physician in Calgary, Alta. They are both board members with Canadian Doctors for Medicare.
Govind Rao

Striking nurses 'stressed' about patients - Infomart - 0 views

  • The St. Catharines Standard Sat Apr 11 2015
  • Tammy McCormick Ferguson was alone at home Friday morning, waiting for a nurse she expected to see at 8 a.m.
  • he 48-year-old niagara Falls woman is in a wheelchair. She is non-verbal, unable to communicate except by messages on her ipad, and requires feeding and medication to be administered twice a day through a tube in her stomach. this is all new to her -until recently, she enjoyed an award-winning career in child development, before a neurological disorder took away not only her career but her ability to look after herself. She is one of 1,600 people in the niagara region who receives treatment from Carepartner nurses. Some clients are able to visit one of four clinics in the region, but she is one of many who receives nursing care at home. But Carepartner nurses went on strike Friday morning, unable to negotiate a contract agreement with their employer.
  • ...1 more annotation...
  • Carepartners' registered nurses, registered practical nurses and administrative staff became members of the Ontario public Service employees union local 294 two years ago, but have yet to sign their first contract. Carepartners is a private, for-profit agency under contract to the Community Care access Centre, delivering nursing services such as dialysis, wound treatment and oncology care to patients who, without those services, might otherwise require hospital stays or long-term care. Ferguson had known for some time her nurses were going on strike, but was assured someone would arrive for the treatment she receives at 8 a.m. and again at 3 p.m., said her mother, dorcas McCormick. When nobody showed up, she messaged her mother, who lives in port Colborne, and McCormick began scrambling to find help for her daughter. McCormick said she could get to the Falls, but doesn't have the training to administer feeding or medication. a nurse finally arrived, but three and a half hours late, she said.
Govind Rao

"National Checkup" panel debates the pros, cons and questions surrounding a universal d... - 0 views

  • THE NATIONAL Thu Mar 19 2015,
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): All that medicine isn't cheap either. Canadians spent an estimated 22 billion dollars a year on prescriptions in 2013, almost twice what they spent in 2001. One in ten struggle to afford it. It's big business and big drug companies know it, spending billions marketing it right back to you. VOICE OF UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN (ANNOUNCER): (Advertisement) Ask your doctor if Lunesta is right for you. WENDY MESLEY (HOST):
  • So are we over- or under-medicated? Is the high cost of prescription drugs failing to help Canadians in need? And what should we be watching for next? So we'll start with that middle question, like, who is not covered? Who is falling through the cracks? You must all see this in your practices? Danielle, what are you seeing? DANIELLE MARTIN (FAMILY PHYSICIAN, WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): In fact, millions of Canadians have no drug coverage whatsoever and millions more don't have adequate coverage for their needs. In my practice I see it all the time among the self-employed, people who are working in small businesses, people who are working part-time and don't have employer-based coverage. It's the taxi drivers, it's the people who are working in a part-time job, but it's also middle-income people who are consultants or working in small businesses who don't have coverage. So this isn't just a problem for the poor. It's a problem for people across socioeconomic lines.
  • ...20 more annotations...
  • DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): Well, I think it's probably not divided properly and I also think that we need to be very mindful of the ways in which advertising and marketing, whether it's direct to patients or consumers as we often consume from the American media on our television screens, or whether it's direct to physicians. So, you know, in fact, even in the U.S. under the Affordable Care Act, physicians are now required to declare any amount of money that they take from the pharmaceutical industry. We have no such sunshine law here in Canada. Don't Canadian patients want to know if your doctor has had their vacation or their last meal or their speakers' fees paid by the company that makes the drug they have just prescribed for you? WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Well, we saw in those ads they'll say: Ask your doctor. Is there a lot of pressure and is that contributing to the number of pills on the market? SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK):
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): What are you seeing, David? DAVID HENRY (PROFESSOR, DALLA LANA SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO): I think this is right and it's a surprise to somebody from outside of Canada to find that in a country with a good comprehensive care system, there is not drug coverage. So patients with chronic disease, for instance diabetics, ironically in the city where insulin was discovered, are relying on free handouts from their physicians to provide what is really an essential medication; it's keeping them alive. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Who do you think is falling through the cracks? What are you seeing?
  • CARA TANNENBAUM (GERIATRIC PHYSICIAN, PHARMACY CHAIR, UNIVERSITÉ DE MONTRÉAL): The vulnerable population in my mind are older adults with multiple medical conditions who are taking 5, 10, 15 medications at the same time and have to pay the deductible on that. And that adds up for a lot of them who don't have a lot of money to begin with, so they start making choices about will I take my drugs until the end of the month? Will I take every single medication that I have to? Do I really need those three medications for my high blood pressure, or can I let one go? And that could have effects on their health. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Well, you mentioned diabetes, David. We heard earlier on "The National" this week from a woman in B.C. She has diabetes. That's a life-threatening disease if it's not looked after. This is what she said.
  • SASHA JANICH (PHON.) (DIABETES PATIENT): Roughly about 600 to 800 bucks a month. I don't get any help until I spend at last 3500 a year and then they'll kick in, you know, whatever portion they decide to cover. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): So, David, that's really common? People on diabetes aren't fully covered?
  • DAVID HENRY (PROFESSOR, DALLA LANA SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO): Well, they're covered to a degree in B.C., but it's what we call the co- payment level that they have to make even under an insurance program. In Ontario, they don't have any insurance at all. They're going to pay the full market price if they don't have insurance through their employer, and they may lose that if they're out of work. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): What are you seeing? What's not covered? Give me an example. DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL):
  • Well, actually, one thing that I think is surprising to a lot of people is the variability in coverage among public drug plans in Canada. So something that's covered, even if you're covered under a public drug plan, for example if you have cancer and you have to take chemotherapy outside of the hospital, in many Canadian provinces that's taken care of. In Ontario, for example, it's not. And I think that many Canadians are surprised to discover, imagine the, you know, enormous stress of a cancer diagnosis, that on top of that you're going to have to pay out of pocket at least to very… sometimes to very, very high levels, in fact. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Samir? SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): And even just the other day, I just was debating with a pharmacy about the cost of some vitamin D. I have a person who's under house, he's on social assistance, and they said: We'll give you a free blister pack, you know, so he can sort his meds. We'll give you this. And we were actually, you know, working out a pricing system so this guy could even afford something so that he wouldn't break bones and actually have a fracture down the road. So it's amazing how some of the basic things we think are important aren't even covered. WENDY MESLEY (HOST):
  • Well, we saw that the drug costs have almost doubled in the last 11, 12 years. Is part of the problem… there's only so much, it seems, money to go around for prescription drugs. Is part of the problem that there's too many… some drugs are too easily available while people who really need them are not getting them? And there's marketing playing into that. We see a lot of ads in the last ten years. Check this out. VOICE OF UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN (ANNOUNCER): (Advertisement) We know a place where tossing and turning have given way to sleeping, where sleepless nights yield to restful sleep. And Lunesta can help you get there.
  • UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (Advertisement) Anyone with high cholesterol may be at increased risk of heart attack. I stopped kidding myself. VOICE OF UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2 (ANNOUNCER): (Advertisement) Talk to your doctor about your risk. VOICE OF UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN (ANNOUNCER): (Advertisement) Ask your doctor if Lunesta is right for you.
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): It's funny, you know, we hear our health plan discussed in the United States and now you talk about our socialized medicine and it's sort of until you have a health problem, you assume everything is covered. But who falls through the cracks that you see, Samir? SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): Yeah, I mean, I treat a lot of older patients and those who are 65 and older generally are covered by a provincial drug plan. But, you know, I'm seeing more and more, especially after the recent recession, we have people who are closer to that age who lose their jobs and if they lose their jobs and they were relying on private drug coverage plans, they are not covered. And then they find themselves they can't afford their medications, they get sicker and they literally have to wait and be sick until they can actually get their medications.
  • Well, it's a huge amount of pressure, I think, you know, for… you know, if you're a doctor that relies on information or supports from pharmaceutical representatives, for example, then there is that pressure that you're put under, there is that influence that you have. But also, we know that if your patient asks you specifically and says, you know, what about this medication, you may say, well, it's easier to prescribe you that medication if that's what you really want. But there's actually five things you can do to improve your sleep and actually avoid being on that medication, but we don't get asked for that. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): But I want to be like the lady with the wings.
  • SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): And that's what I hear: Why can't I be like that? But I think it's important to think about the other options. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): David, what do you think? DAVID HENRY (PROFESSOR, DALLA LANA SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO): I would like to focus a little bit on the prices that are being paid. We talked about usage and whether drug use is appropriate. There's also the price that is paid. Canada is paying too much. And if we can just return for a second or two to the idea of a national program, there's a huge advantage in being the sole purchaser on behalf of 35 million people, as it would be with a national program in Canada. And we know from experience you can reduce drug prices by 30, 40 percent. That's billions of dollars a year. WENDY MESLEY (HOST):
  • That's a political debate that you have launched and I hope that it gets taken up by the politicians. Who is buying these drugs? We have seen that there are more people having trouble getting drugs, more people using drugs. Who is it? DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): That are taking prescription drugs in Canada? WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Yeah. DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL):
  • Well, you know, interestingly over the last decade, we have seen an increase in prescription drug use in every single age category. So the answer is we all are. We're all taking more drugs than our equivalent people did a decade ago and I think… WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Teenagers? DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): Absolutely, teenagers and the elderly and everybody in between. And so the question really becomes: Are we any healthier as a result? You know, in some cases we're talking about truly life-saving treatment that are medical breakthroughs and, of course, we all want to see every Canadian have unfettered access to those important treatments. In other cases we may actually be talking about overdiagnosis, overprescription and as you say, Cara, sort of chemical coping of all different kinds. And I think that's what we need to kind of get at and try to tease out. WENDY MESLEY (HOST):
  • Well, and the largest group of all on prescription drugs right now, Cara, are the seniors. CARA TANNENBAUM (GERIATRIC PHYSICIAN, PHARMACY CHAIR, UNIVERSITÉ DE MONTRÉAL): The seniors, yes, and I'm very passionate about this topic because sometimes I see patients come into my office on 23 different drug classes, and that's when we don't talk about what drugs should we add but what drugs can we take away, and the concept of de-prescribing. And imagine if we could get people who are on unnecessary drugs, because as you get older you get added this drug and a second drug and this specialist gives you this and that specialist gives you that, but then there starts to be interactions between the different drugs that could cause side effects and hospitalization. And maybe it's time to start asking, well, what's the right drug for you at this time, at this age, with these medical conditions? And personalized medicine is something that we have been talking about. It would be nice if we could introduce that conversation into therapy and not just drug therapy, but all therapy. Maybe the drug isn't needed. Maybe physiotherapy is needed or a psychologist or better exercise or nutrition. So I think it's really a bigger question. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Samir?
  • SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): Exactly. I mean, in my clinic the other day I had a patient who was on eight medications when she came with me, and… WENDY MESLEY (HOST): This is a senior? You deal with seniors as well. SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): Absolutely. And when she left my office, she was thrilled because she was only on two medications, mainly because some of the medications are prescribed to treat the side effects of other medications, for example, or the indications for those medications were no longer valid in her. But we added some vitamins and we just balanced things out appropriately. And she was thrilled because, as Cara was saying before, the co-pays, the other payments that one needs to pay for medications you don't want to take, that's a problem as well. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): We're going to take a short break, but we have one more discussion area which is: What are the next challenges that Canadians might face with prescription drugs? We'll be right back.
  • (Commercial break) WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Welcome back to our "National Checkup" panel. Danielle Martin, Samir Sinha, Cara Tannenbaum and David Henry are all here to talk about the next frontier. So we're hearing all of this exciting new science marches on and there's all of these new drugs, new treatments. Everyone wants them or everyone who needs them wants them, but they're expensive, right, Danielle? DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): They can be extremely expensive. So, you know, what we call these blockbuster drugs coming onto the market, some of them truly do represent breakthroughs in medical treatment and in some cases they can cost tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. So they really are very expensive. But what I think many people may not realize is that the number of drugs coming out, even the expensive ones that are truly breakthroughs, is still a very small portion of the drugs coming out on the market. Many, many drugs that are being released and are expensive are marginally, if at all, really any better than their predecessor. So just because it's new and fancy and costs a lot doesn't necessarily mean that it's all that much better.
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): So what's going to happen, David? DAVID HENRY (PROFESSOR, DALLA LANA SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO): We need to find a plan. These drugs may cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Nobody can afford that individually. Tens of thousands, rich people can afford them but the average person cannot. So there's really no way we can cope with these unless we've got a plan and, in my view, it has to be a national plan. And the advantage of that are that when you're buying or you're subsidizing on behalf of 35 million people, you're going to get better prices and your insurance pool that covers these costs is much greater. So the country can afford drugs that individuals can't.
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Samir, what do you see as the new frontier here? SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): I think the new frontier is going to be more personalized treatments in terms of how do we actually treat cancers, how do we treat certain rare conditions with more personalized treatments. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Because it's very exciting, right? You have this cancer that's not that common and then you hear that there's a treatment for it and you want it. SAMIR SINHA (GERIATRICIAN, MOUNT SINAI/UNIVERSITY HEALTH NETWORK): And it has the possibility of alleviating a lot of suffering from unnecessary treatments that may not actually be… you know, be effective. But I think this is the challenge. If we want to be able to afford these, if we actually work together we're actually more able to afford them when we bulk-buy these medications. But the key is going to be that, you know, this is where the future is going and we're going to have to figure out a way to pay for them.
  • WENDY MESLEY (HOST): What are you looking forward to? CARA TANNENBAUM (GERIATRIC PHYSICIAN, PHARMACY CHAIR, UNIVERSITÉ DE MONTRÉAL): I'm really looking forward to seeing all these new treatments that we have spent decades researching. You know what the investment in health research has been in order to find new targets for drugs, in order to increase quality of live, in order to cure cancer, and then to send a message, oh, sorry, we're not going to give them to you or you can't afford to pay for them, then I think there is a lack of consistency in the messaging that we're giving to Canadians around equity for health care. So you could get your diagnosis and you could see a physician, but we way not be able to afford treating you. So I think this is something we need to think about it. It's very exciting, I think we live in exciting times, and looking at different funding strategies to make sure that people get the appropriate care that they need at the right time to improve their health is really what we're going to be looking forward to. WENDY MESLEY (HOST):
  • Tricky, though. It's a provincial jurisdiction, you've got to get all the provinces to agree to a list, and the list is getting longer. DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): Absolutely. I mean, I think actually one of the big myths out there about drug plans is that higher-quality plans are the ones that cover everything. And, in fact, that's not true. You know, we can use a national plan or a pan- Canadian plan or whatever you want to call it to target our prescribing and guide our prescribing in order to make it more appropriate, and that's another way that we're going to save money in the long run. WENDY MESLEY (HOST): Well, I learned a lot tonight. I hope our audience did too. Thanks so much for being with us. DANIELLE MARTIN (WOMEN'S COLLEGE HOSPITAL): Thank you.
Govind Rao

Ambulance fees unfair, dangerous obstacle to care - Infomart - 0 views

  • Toronto Star Fri Mar 27 2015
  • Imagine you're a physician seeing a 6-month-old child in clinic. She has a fever and cough, she's working hard to breathe and her oxygen levels are falling. You know she needs assessment in the emergency room and requires transportation in an ambulance in case her condition worsens en route. Her family understands the urgency of the situation, but asks, "Could we take her there in our car?" Experiencing a medical emergency is an incredibly stressful experience for patients and their families. This stress should not be compounded by worries about getting an ambulance bill they can't afford. As physicians, we know the importance of the first few minutes of an emergency situation, and the crucial role of Emergency Medical Services (EMS) in saving lives. And yet ambulance fees remain a significant barrier to people receiving necessary care across Canada.
  • One young mother recently spoke to the Saskatchewan press about receiving a bill of $7,000 after several ambulance trips were required for her severely ill daughter. Connie Newman of the Manitoba Association of Seniors Centres recently described to reporters the plight of an elderly woman who walked to the hospital in -40 C because she could not afford an ambulance. How often are people forced to choose the unsafe option of driving themselves or their loved ones to hospital simply because they cannot afford to pay? A recent CBC Marketplace survey revealed that 19 per cent of Canadians did not call an ambulance due to cost. Clearly, this is an issue that our provincial and territorial health ministers need to address. A look across our provinces and territories reveals a patchwork system for financing ambulance services. New Brunswick has recently removed ambulance fees for anyone who does not have private insurance coverage. All other provinces and territories in Canada - with the exception of the Yukon - charge ambulance fees. The burden of cost to patients is highest in the prairies: Manitoba charges up to $530 per trip, and Saskatchewan tacks on fees for interhospital transfers on top of the $245-$325 fee for an ambulance pickup from home.
  • ...3 more annotations...
  • In Ontario, the cost is typically much lower at $45 per trip, but increases to $240 if the receiving physician deems it unnecessary. The reality on the ground violates the spirit, if not the letter, of the Canada Health Act: Equal access to physician and hospital services means little if safe passage to them is anything but. There are a variety of options to reduce this inequity in access. One option is to follow New Brunswick's lead and offer full coverage. An alternative would be to only charge users if the ambulance ride is deemed medically unnecessary. However, differentiating "appropriate" from "inappropriate" ambulance use isn't straightforward, and can vary between providers. What's more, evidence suggests that institutions - schools, long-term care facilities, hospitals and police services - more often initiate potentially unnecessary ambulance services than do individuals, as a result of compliance with internal policy or protocol.
  • As with other areas of health care, user fees are a blunt tool: they reduce both necessary and unnecessary use of services. The risk of footing the bill could deter people, especially those living in poverty, from calling for help. This would deny them not only safe transport to hospital, but also the initial emergency interventions by paramedics that can mean the difference between life and death. Public education and enhanced availability of primary care are more effective ways to decrease unnecessary ambulance use. Ideally, ambulance services should be fully covered for everyone. This would, however, require provincial governments to take on more of the costs. In Nova Scotia, that cost is an estimated $9.7 million, according to the Nova Scotia Citizen's Health Care Network. This is a drop in the bucket of the $6.2-billion Nova Scotia health-care budget; a small investment to ensure everyone, regardless of income, has access to vital emergency care. The variety and inequity of ambulance charges in Canada is a policy mess. Canada's health ministers should work together to establish a consistent and compassionate approach that balances cost with the need to remove barriers to care. Ryan Meili is an expert adviser
  • with EvidenceNetwork.ca, a family physician in Saskatoon and founder of Upstream: Institute for a Healthy Society. @ryanmeili Carolyn Nowry is a family physician in Calgary. They are both board members with Canadian Doctors for Medicare.
Govind Rao

Canada needs 'coalition of the willing' to fix health care - Infomart - 0 views

  • The Globe and Mail Wed Nov 18 2015
  • apicard@globeandmail.com What country has the world's best health system? That is one of those unanswerable questions that health-policy geeks like to ponder and debate. There have even been serious attempts at measuring and ranking. In 2000, the World Health Organization (in)famously produced a report that concluded that France had the world's best health system, followed by those of Italy, San Marino, Andorra and Malta.
  • The business publication Bloomberg produces an annual ranking that emphasizes value for money from health spending; the 2014 ranking places Singapore on top, followed by Hong Kong, Italy, Japan and South Korea. The Economist Intelligence Unit compares 166 countries, and ranks Japan as No. 1, followed by Singapore, Switzerland, Iceland and Australia. The Commonwealth Fund ranks health care in 11 Western countries and gives the nod to the U.K., followed by Switzerland, Sweden, Australia and Germany. The problem with these exercises is that no one can really agree on what should be measured and, even when they do settle on measures, data are not always reliable and comparable.
  • ...6 more annotations...
  • "Of course, there is no such thing as a perfect health system and it certainly doesn't reside in any one country," Mark Britnell, global chairman for health at the consulting giant KPMG, writes in his new book, In Search of the Perfect Health System. "But there are fantastic examples of great health and health care from around the world which can offer inspiration."
  • As a consultant who has worked in 60 countries - and who receives in-depth briefings on the health systems of each before meeting clients - Mr. Britnell has a unique perspective and, in the book, offers up a subjective and insightful list of the traits that are important to creating good health systems. If the world had a perfect health system, he writes, it would have the following qualities: the values and universal access of the U.K.; the primary care of Israel; the community services of Brazil; the mentalhealth system of Australia; the health promotion philosophy of the Nordic countries; the patient and community empowerment in parts of Africa; the research and development infrastructure of the United States; the innovation, flair and speed of India; the information, communications and technology of Singapore; the choice offered to patients in France; the funding model of Switzerland; and the care for the aged of Japan.
  • In the book, Mr. Britnell elaborates on each of these examples of excellence and, in addition, provides a great precis of the strengths and weaknesses of health systems in 25 countries. The chapter on Canada is appropriately damning, noting that this country's outmoded health system has long been ripe for revolution, but the "revolution has not happened."
  • Why? Because this country has a penchant for doing high-level, in-depth reviews of the health system's problems, but puts all its effort into producing recommendations and none into implementing them. Ouch. "Canada stands at a crossroads," Mr. Britnell writes, "and needs to find the political will and managerial and clinical skills to establish a progressive coalition of the willing."
  • The book's strength is that it does not offer up simplistic solutions. Rather, it stresses that there is no single best approach because all health systems are the products of their societies, norms and cultures. One of the best parts of the book - and quite relevant to Canada - is the analysis of funding models. "The debate about universal health care is frequently confused with the ability to pay," Mr. Britnell writes. He notes that the high co-payments in the highly praised health systems of Asia would simply not be tolerated in the West.
  • But ultimately what matters is finding an approach that works, not a perfect one: "This is the fundamental point. There is no such thing as free health care; it is only a matter of who pays for it. Politics is the imperfect art of deciding 'who gets what, how and when.' " The book stresses that the challenges are the same everywhere: providing high-quality care to all at an affordable price, finding the work force to deliver that care and empowering patients. To do so effectively, you need vision and you need systems. Above all, you need the political will to learn from others and put in place a system that works.
Govind Rao

Drug prices expected to jump as result of trade deal - Infomart - 0 views

  • The Globe and Mail Mon Dec 7 2015
  • The intellectual-property provisions in the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement will drive up global drug prices and make it harder to treat diseases in developing countries, Medecins sans Frontieres (Doctors Without Borders) says. A month after the final text of the TPP was released, the medical humanitarian organization has completed its analysis of the portions of the massive trade pact that will affect drug costs.
  • Despite changes from earlier leaked versions of the text, there are still serious problems, Judit Rius, MSF's U.S. legal policy adviser, said. "This is catastrophic. This is very negative. The impact is going to be at multiple levels," Ms. Rius said in an interview. "First of all, it is going to delay access to generic competition [for brand-name drugs], which is a proven intervention to reduce the price of medicines."
  • ...6 more annotations...
  • Ms. Rius said there were six problem areas - from MSF's perspective - in the early leaked versions of the TPP. Three have been eliminated in the final text, although she said some of those were "absurd" in the first place. Among them was a provision that would have made it illegal to oppose a patent before it was granted and another that would have forced governments to allow surgical techniques to be patented. There are three key remaining problem provisions, according to the MSF analysis. One would allow pharmaceutical companies to "evergreen" their product patents, essentially making small changes to a drug's use to extend its protection from competition. Another would extend patent protection if there are delays in regulatory approval of a new product.
  • More broadly, allowing greater monopoly protection for brand-name drug makers will diminish innovation at other firms, Ms. Rius said. "If you are trying to develop a pediatric formulation of a product, if you are trying to combine different pills into one pill, ... if you are trying to improve a medicine and create a second generation, all of that technology and knowledge is going to be protected by secondary patents." The final text of the sweeping trade pact, which has been in the works for eight years, was released in early November. Canada is one of 12 countries that have negotiated the pact, although it was the former Conservative government that signed on. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said his government will wait for parliamentary hearings on the TPP before deciding on ratification. Each country has to ratify the agreement before it comes into effect.
  • For generic drug makers, she said, the TPP will create additional legal barriers that will get in the way of making new products, and that will stunt the industry. The TPP will actually raise drug prices, especially in developing countries, she said, and this "will affect our capacity, and the capacity of the ministries of health with whom we work, to scale up treatment programs and reach as many people as needed."
  • A third would allow developers of certain advanced drugs - called biologics - to keep their clinical data private for up to eight years. That would make it much tougher for competitors to create similar drugs, or at least delay that from happening. This "data exclusivity" rule would be new for some of the countries that are part of the TPP group, although Canada already has a similar provision in place. Indeed, many of the provisions of the TPP are already part of the Canadian scene, at least in some form, said trade lawyer Larry Herman, of Herman & Associates in Toronto. The former Conservative government had said the TPP was "in line" with Canada's existing patent laws, and this appears to be true from his read of that part of the text, Mr. Herman said.
  • Still, he said, from a global perspective "there is no doubt that the agreement increases patent protection and enhances the monopoly rights of the patent owner." From the perspective of Canada's generic drug industry, the TPP has to be looked at in conjunction with the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) between Canada and the European Union, said Jim Keon, president of the Canadian Generic Pharmaceutical Association.
  • CETA, which has not yet taken effect, would extend patent protection for drugs and cut into the business of Canadian generic drug makers - thus boosting drug costs - Mr. Keon said. But it also contains some specific protection for the generic industry to mitigate that impact. It is not clear yet whether the TPP will allow those mitigating measures to be implemented in Canada, he said. And because of the immense complexity of the TPP, "you've got all sorts of potential for misinterpretation here," Mr. Keon added.
Govind Rao

In the News: Health Care Wait Times - What is the Real Story? - Ontario Health Coalition - 0 views

  • December 8, 2015
  • By: Natalie Mehra, Executive Director, Ontario Health Coalition Today, a high-profile report tracking health care wait times was released from the Wait Times Alliance. Eliminating Code Gridlock in Canada’s Health Care System, is a credible summary and a useful addition to public policy decisions about health care planning. It is written by an alliance of physician specialists’ organizations to track progress in wait times and public reporting.
  • Fraser Institute
  • ...17 more annotations...
  • Fraser Institute
  • Both reports are about wait times in health care.
  • response rate is only 21%.
  • Though the report does not say this, many of these waits are due to a severe shortage of hospital beds. (Ontario has cut more beds than anywhere in Canada.)
  • public hospital system including better wait list management and pooled referrals, additional operating room nurses and health professionals have improved wait times in Saskatchewan.
  • Ontario has one of the most robust reporting systems in the country,
  • On the negative side, most provinces do not report their wait times on most procedures, so the report is based on limited information and only from those provinces that do report.
  • So, focusing on the report that is worth looking at – The Wait Times Alliance report is a thought-provoking addition to the body of research on access to care and timeliness of care.
  • Long waits in hospital emergency departments were cited in Ontario. Waits are up to 26 hours for Ontario patients with complex conditions that require additional diagnostic tests or admission into a hospital bed.
  • These are good recommendations that we should support.
  • There is only really one item with which we would take issue in the report: there is considerable confusion about Alternate Level of Care (ALC) patients.T
  • one type of hospital bed waiting for another type of hospital bed (not waiting for discharge to long-term care or home care).
  • Unfortunately, this misinformation is driving dangerous levels of hospital cuts.
  • There is also a gratuitous positive mention of the LEAN methods in the report, without any real analysis. We receive endless complaints about this Toyota management system that is now being used in public hospitals.
  • askatchewan Premier Brad Wahl,
  • Instead the evidence is that patients in those provinces are being charged fees ranging from hundreds to tens of thousands of dollars for medically-needed care.
  • On top of these user fees, private clinics are billing the public system — for the same procedures. I
Govind Rao

The stars align for a pan-Canadian pharmacare plan - Infomart - 0 views

  • Toronto Star Fri Oct 23 2015
  • Canada can - and should - move pharmacare from its perennial wish list to its under-construction file, says a new report from the C.D. Howe Institute. It is feasible right now to guarantee every Canadian access to medically necessary drugs, the authors contend.
  • Colin Busby, a senior policy analyst at the institute and Ake Blomqvist, a health economist at Carleton, acknowledge their model won't please everyone. It wouldn't bring drug coverage into medicare. But it would break the political logjam that has obstructed progress for so long. It would bring down the "runaway cost" pharmaceuticals. And it would help low-income patients fill their prescriptions.
  • ...7 more annotations...
  • "In our view, recent proposals for a universal pharmacare plan under which governments would pay essentially all drug costs with only very limited patient charges, are not realistic," Busby and Blomqvist argue. "We believe it is time to start moving toward a model that makes important inroads into the biggest shortcomings of the expensive and flawed system we have today." They point to five critical deficiencies:
  • Too many low-income people can't afford to fill their prescriptions. All Canadians pay too much for essential medications. The provinces have no common formulary, meaning the list of insured drugs varies across the country. People with rare diseases who need exceptionally expensive drugs have to beg the government or the manufacturer for help.
  • Fortuitously, the report - written before this week's election - dovetails nicely with the approach of Canada's new Liberal government. Prime minister-designate Justin Trudeau has promised to "improve access to necessary prescription medications" and "work with the provinces and territories to buy drugs in bulk." That isn't quite pharmacare, but it is similar to what Busby and Blomqvist are recommending. Under the C.D. Howe plan, Ottawa would top up health transfers to the provinces allowing them to ensure that drug costs do not exceed 3 per cent of family income anywhere in Canada. (For a single working parent with two children earning $30,000, the ceiling would be $900. For a two-earner family with two children with an income of $115,500 - the national average - the maximum would be $3,450).
  • There is no mechanism to improve the quality of prescribing by physicians. The key to addressing all these problems, the authors say, is an increased role for the federal government in drug financing. Ottawa wouldn't run the program or deliver the drugs; it would provide the cash and co-ordination to bring the existing provincial programs up to an acceptable national standard.
  • All of the provinces currently have upper limits but they vary from 3 per cent to 12 per cent of family income. Ontario's is 4 per cent. Ottawa would become a partner in the Pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance launched by the premiers and territorial leaders in 2010 to bulk-purchase prescription drugs. This would increase its financial muscle - the federal government supplies medications to the prison population, First Nations, soldiers and veterans - when negotiating drug prices. It would also allow the federal government to play a co-ordinating role in creation of a single national drug formulary, based on transparent clinical evidence of cost-effectiveness.
  • Ottawa would work with the provinces to design a national strategy for rare and high-cost diseases. Similarly it would help them build incentives into their drug plans for doctors to take responsibility for the cost of the prescriptions they write. There would be no fundamental restructuring. A substantial share of drug costs would continue to be privately funded. The disruption would be minimal. Work could begin immediately. Politically the stars are as well-aligned as they are likely to be. The provincial premiers invited Ottawa to join the Pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance in June. Their health ministers agreed that Ottawa should play a role in improving access to prescription drugs and coverage for low-income Canadians. Trudeau has promised to negotiate a long-term health accord with the premiers and budgeted an additional $415 million for health care next year rising to $1 billion by 2019. And more than 90 per cent of Canadians support universal access to prescription drugs.
  • "Canadians need improvements to the existing arrangements," Busby and Blomqvist point out. "What we propose would go a long toward achieving the same objectives as those of the federally funded universal drug plan." The question facing Canadians who have waited decades for a national publicly funded pharmacare program is: Do they settle for watered down version or hold out for the gold standard? They could wait a very long time. Carol Goar's column appears Monday, Wednesday and Friday.
« First ‹ Previous 561 - 575 of 575
Showing 20 items per page