Skip to main content

Home/ anth103bagainstlangthought/ Contents contributed and discussions participated by Ted Delia

Contents contributed and discussions participated by Ted Delia

Ted Delia

Sapir- Whorf hypothesis - 4 views

started by Ted Delia on 17 Feb 11 no follow-up yet
  • Ted Delia
     
    Sapir-Whorf hypothesis


    Sapir-Whorf hypothesis This hypothesis-a position of linguistic relativity-argues that (to quote one of its authors) language 'is not merely a reproducing instrument for voicing ideas, but is itself a shaper of ideas, the programme and guide for the individual's meaningful activity'. In short, language determines (or shapes) our perceptions of reality. The classic literary example of this is the 'newspeak' of the totalitarian rulers of George Orwell's 1984. The most famous commonly cited examples in social science are probably those of the Hanunoo, who have 92 names for rice, each conveying a different reality, and the Eskimo, who have over a hundred words for snow. Such fine differentiation permits these cultures to see important facets of their culture more clearly.

    This is an important theory and there is broad truth in the argument that language plays a role in shaping reality. But it should not be overstated and collapse into extreme relativism: there seem also to be linguistic universals, or features common to every language; and words are often invented to reflect, rather than construct new phenomena in reality. (In the case of microwave ovens, for example, we need the word 'microwave' to depict a real phenomenon-not to invent the ovens themselves.)

    This last part talking about microwaves can be used as proof because language can be created just to explain reality and whats going on.
Ted Delia

Overweiw of different approaches - 1 views

linguistic relativity hypothesis
started by Ted Delia on 17 Feb 11 no follow-up yet
1 - 2 of 2
Showing 20 items per page