Christianity: Foundation of Western Success - 4 views
-
At the core of Stark's investigation is his argument that specific ideas innate to Judaism (especially that found in Diaspora Jewish communities) and Christianity played a pivotal role in enabling the West to make and sustain political, legal and economic breakthroughs that eluded other civilizations. First and foremost, Jews and Christians viewed God as a rational Creator. In that sense, God was not at all like the Greco-Roman deities — capricious, self-indulgent beings for the most part. Moreover, the Christians, from the very beginning, not only understood the need to reason out the implications of Christ's teachings; they also viewed reason as the great gift which God gave man to know the truth about the Creator but also the world He created in order that humans might help unfold God's design. The second religious ingredient of the West's success, Stark maintains, was Christianity's unwillingness to attribute life's ups-and-downs to fate. Unlike the pagan (and many contemporary) religions, the Jewish and Christian "conception of God is incompatible with fate" (p. 120). It is true, Stark writes, that particular pagans such as Cicero had a somewhat similar view of free will. The difference is that belief in free will was more than simply a philosophical tenet for Jews and Christians. It was also a matter of specific religious conviction, which meant, furthermore, that people could — and would — be held accountable for their free choices before the same rational God who had given them free will.
-
Aaron Peters on 27 Mar 14Describe the two fundamental contributions to western society by Christianity according to the source.
-
-
It is in the medieval period, Stark maintains, that perhaps the most significant flowering of this commitment to reason and free will took place — and not just in the universities that were first built by the Christians. The key, as Stark puts it so precisely, was the Christian commitment to "the pursuit of knowledge. Not to illumination. Not to enlightenment. Not to wisdom. But to knowledge. And the basis for this commitment to knowledge was the Christian commitment to theology" (p. 159). From this flowed, among other things, the enterprise of natural philosophy. That in turn underlay the development of the scientific method that first acquired real momentum in medieval Europe, as well as, Stark emphasizes, the emergence of key economic insights and institutions that promoted and relied upon freedom.
-
With regard to the latter, Stark illustrates that the central foundations for modern capitalism — "the rise of banking, elaborate manufacturing networks, rapid innovations in technology and finance, and a busy network of trading cities" (p. 181) — were very much products of medieval Christianity, especially in Northern Italy, Flanders, and, by the early-thirteenth century, England. In this light, Stark argues, we begin to see that industrial capitalism didn't appear out of nowhere in the late-eighteenth century. In Stark's words, the Industrial Revolution "was not a revolution at all but part of an evolution of invention and innovation that had begun … perhaps as early as the eleventh century" (p. 184).