There are a few reasons why smiley is a better solution:
Webkit+Font Management software can mess up local references, like turning glyphs into A blocks. (crbug.com/33173)
On OS X, Font Management software may alter system settings to show a dialog when trying to access a local() font that's accessible outside of Library/Fonts. More detail on my bulletproof post. (crbug.com/29729) Font Explorer X is also known to mess up other stuff in Firefox: bugzil.la/531771
Although it's unlikely, you could reference a local() font which is completely different than what you think it is. (Typophile post on different fonts, same name) At the very least its a risk, and you're ceding control of the type to both the browser and host machine. This risk may not be worth the benefit of avoiding the font download.
These are all pretty edge case issues, but it's worth considering. FontSquirrel has already made the smiley syntax the new default in the Generator, and you should use it going forward as well.
Group items matching
in title, tags, annotations or url
1More
Digging out the Archive with these Blog Customization Ideas - 0 views
VIZUALIZE: Archive - 6 views
1More
White Blue Studio Flash Website Template - 0 views
HTTP Archive Mobile - 5 views
SillyDog701 NetScape Browser Archive - 0 views
SillyDog701 NetScape Browser Archive - 0 views
HTTP Archive - 10 views
6More