This morning, the Second Circuit issued a follow-on ruling to its May decision in ACLU v. Clapper (which had held that the NSA’s bulk telephone records program was unlawful insofar as it had not properly been authorized by Congress). In a nutshell, today’s ruling rejects the ACLU’s request for an injunction against the continued operation of the program for the duration of the 180-day transitional period (which ends on November 29) from the old program to the quite different collection regime authorized by the USA Freedom Act. As the Second Circuit (in my view, quite correctly) concluded, “Regardless of whether the bulk telephone metadata program was illegal prior to May, as we have held, and whether it would be illegal after November 29, as Congress has now explicitly provided, it is clear that Congress intended to authorize it during the transitionary period.”
So far, so good. But remember that the ACLU’s challenge to bulk collection was mounted on both statutory and constitutional grounds, the latter of which the Second Circuit was able to avoid in its earlier ruling because of its conclusion that, prior to the enactment of the USA Freedom Act, bulk collection was unauthorized by Congress. Now that it has held that it is authorized during the transitional period, that therefore tees up, quite unavoidably, whether bulk collection violates the Fourth Amendment. But rather than decide that (momentous) question, the Second Circuit ducked:
Group items matching
in title, tags, annotations or url
3More
1More
The Future of Mobile Software - RoughlyDrafted Magazine - 0 views
3More
Section 215 and "Fruitless" (?!?) Constitutional Adjudication | Just Security - 0 views
3More
Open Source Life: How the open movement will change everything - 1 views
2More
RIAA Says YouTube is Running a DMCA Protection Racket - TorrentFreak - 0 views
2More
The Short, Troubled History of Apple Music | Digital Music News - 0 views
2More
(# ! Another) 5 best Linux distros for beginners and newbies - Computer Business Review - 0 views
1More
Russian Copyright Law Allows Entire News Site To Be Shut Down Over A Single Copied Arti... - 0 views
1More
Google's Fallacious Piracy Self-Study (Part 1) | MUSIC * TECHNOLOGY * POLICY - 1 views
1More
New Download Ban Won't Work, Politicians Say | TorrentFreak - 1 views
2More
Patent Reform Bill A Good Step, But Still Falls Way Short Of Fixing A Broken System | T... - 0 views
1More
Learn it Faster: The Complete Linux Kernel in a Single Map - 1 views
1More
Mozilla restarts work on multi-process Firefox | InfoWorld - 0 views
1More