Skip to main content

Home/ Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment/ Group items tagged criticism

Rss Feed Group items tagged

Susan Bistrican

Quotations on Dostoevsky as a writer - 0 views

  • “Russia’s evil genius,” -- Maxim Gorky (1905)
  • Henry James described Dostoevsky’s works as “baggy monsters” and “fluid puddings”, with a profound “lack of composition” and a “defiance of economy and architecture.
  • And to "CRIME & PUNISHMENT"... "Raskolnikov lived his true life when he was lying on the sofa in his room, deliberating not at all about the old woman, nor even as to whether it is or is not permissible at the will of one man to wipe from the face of the earth another, unnecessary and harmful, man, but whether he ought to live in Petersburg or not, whether he ought to accept money from his mother or not, and on other questions not at all relating to the old woman. And then -- in that region quite independent of animal activities -- the question of whether he would or would not kill the old woman was decided. The question was decided... when he was doing nothing and was only thinking, when only his consciousness was active: and in that consciousness tiny, tiny alterations were taking place. It is at such times that one needs the greatest clearness to decide correctly the questions that have arisen, and it is just then that one glass of beer, or one cigarette, may prevent the solution of the question, may postpone the decision, stifle the voice of conscience and prompt a decision of the question in favor of the lower, animal nature -- as was the case with Raskolnikov. Tiny, tiny alterations -- but on them depend the most immense and terrible consequences." -- Leo Tolstoy on Dostoevsky's Raskolnikov
  •  
    Dostoevsky's work is received differently among his critics who don't always enjoy his work. Though some critics believe that his work is of aesthetic value, the prevailing critique that it is very "Russian" connotes that his work is sometimes macabre and always depressing.
Susan Bistrican

Comparison paper example - 1 views

Use my comparison paper as an example for comparing Crime and Punishment to a philosophical work of your choice. S. Bistrican, 2006 Redemption through Suffering: Reading Crime and Punishmen...

comparison philosophy Dostoevsky Unamuno

started by Susan Bistrican on 27 Jul 11 no follow-up yet
Susan Bistrican

Dostoevsky Papers - 1 views

  • Dostoevsky depicts social issues, especially the problem of murder, through an image of people who go through pain. He presents a graphical experience of ones who do not know how to deal with humanity and its problems. Dostoevsky himself does not give a clear solution nor does he leave one with the certainty of faith for an example.
  •  
    Critical essays written by students at Middlebury College. Use them as a reference for your final analysis due at the end of the semester.
1 - 3 of 3
Showing 20 items per page