OpenDocument's feed | Diigo Group

Patrick Durusau on ODF and interoperability

Thu, 05 Jun 2008 22:18:54 -0000

Highlights and Sticky Notes:

Interoperability is one of the primary reasons why I like XML in general and ODF in particular.

Tags: durusau interop interop myth sources odf

Posted by: marbux

The Stockholm Syndrom at ISO | ODF Editor Says ODF Loses If OOXML Does | Slashdot

Fri, 28 Mar 2008 18:51:08 -0000

Highlights and Sticky Notes:

ISO is bound to the business of "interoperability", and has very strict guidelines for interoperability requirements, that are themselves tied to international trade agreements and legal conventions. In this context, it is beyond surprising that ISO allows the "OASIS PAS" and "Ecma Fast Track" channels to remain open, with specification work remaining under the controlling influence of the vendors.

IMHO, the change in Patrick's position is entirely due to the realization that it is impossible to map between OOXML and ODF. I don't know this for sure, but when i read the German Standards Group (DIN) report on harmonization, authorized by the EU-IDABC and provided to ISO, i couldn't help but wonder how Patrick would react. The report definitively ends his OOXML ODF mapping dream.

Tags: durusau iso microsoft odf ooxml slashdot w3c

Posted by: garyedwards

ODF Editor Says ODF Loses If OOXML Does | Slashdot

Thu, 27 Mar 2008 07:29:21 -0000

Highlights and Sticky Notes:

IMHO, the change in Patrick's position is entirely due to the realization that it is impossible to map between OOXML and ODF. I don't know this for sure, but when i read the German Standards Group (DIN) report on harmonization, authorized by the EU-IDABC and provided to ISO, i couldn't help but wonder how Patrick would react. The report definitively ends his OOXML ODF mapping dream.

Many wonder why mapping is impossible. I had more than a few discussions with Patrick on this. His point was that a schema is a schema. As long as the syntax and semantics are fully documented, no problemo. My point is that both ODF and OOXML are application specific; and, both are woefully lacking in "semantic" documentation. Add to this problem that both ODF and OOXML lack an interoperability framework with any semblance of compliance teeth, and the whole mapping issue becomes an impossible solution. Especially if interop is the goal.

Tags: durusau iso odf ooxml

Posted by: garyedwards

Word of recognition from an unexpected side: ODF editor Patrick Durusau supports OOXML - ISO effort

Thu, 07 Feb 2008 19:04:16 -0000

Highlights and Sticky Notes:

The OpenXML project has made a large amount of progress in terms of the openness of its evelopment. Objections that do not recognize that are focusing on what they want to see and not what is actually happening with OpenXML

Tags: brm durusau iso oasis odf officeopenxml ooxml opendocument openxml

Posted by: garyedwards