Saying that telling someone they are privileged ‘isn’t an insult’ is a bare-faced lie.
I have seen so many feminists, gay and queer and trans activists use the single word ‘privilege’ to dismiss an individual and their arguments I have lost count.
Saying that telling someone they are privileged ‘isn’t an insult’ is a bare-faced lie.
I have seen so many feminists, gay and queer and trans activists use the single word ‘privilege’ to dismiss an individual and their arguments I have lost count.
Take trans politics for example. I am continually labelled as ‘privileged’ as a ‘cis’ woman. And this enables trans people to always be the victim in discussions, the victim of my privileged viewpoint. But I don’t think I have any ‘privilege’ in terms of gender identity. I fail at being a ‘woman’. My sexuality is closest to that of homos, with no access to the physical experiences of homo-men. I have no gender ‘advantages’ I can think of at all, except that I am not going through the pain of transition. Just the pain of a lifetime of ‘not fitting’ to my supposed gender identity.But in conversation with trans people, they can always claim the ‘privileged’ position of the powerless.
I think privilege is used as a weapon in identity politics.
Now, if the racial profile was reversed and four white girls attacked a person of another race, while cajoling and exhorting one another to "kill", then I'm pretty confident a custodial sentence would have been passed.